Iron Man Message Board >> View Post
Post By
The Iron Stark

Member Since: Sat May 17, 2008
Posts: 525
In Reply To
The Mandarin

Member Since: Sat May 17, 2008
Posts: 5,202
Subj: Re: Bendis leaving Marvel for DC
Posted: Tue Nov 07, 2017 at 02:27:05 pm EST (Viewed 212 times)
Reply Subj: Bendis leaving Marvel for DC
Posted: Tue Nov 07, 2017 at 11:32:22 am EST (Viewed 177 times)

Previous Post

Well, now that Bendis is leaving, it's time to review his run as a whole. Personally I found his run charming but flawed.

Riri never seemed to be protecting anyone but herself. I also thought her grief over lost loved ones should have been much more of a living thing, rather than something that just existed in her origin and then never popped up again.

Nonetheless I found Riri herself quite charming and enjoyed the book, at least the first time I read each issue. In fact, I basically went through this cycle each issue: I'd read it, end with a smile on my face, and say to myself, "ah, that was charming. I'm glad I bought that." *fifteen minutes later* "it would be even better if it had some Doctor Who/Buffy style angst about dealing with grief and teenage issues, though"

As for who I'd like to see replace Bendis: I really liked "Penguin: Pain and Prejudice" and would like to see Gregg Hurwitz take a crack at The Mandarin. Stan Lee's origin for the Mandarin combined similar themes of an aristocrat being raised by someone who hated him, fused with X-23ish ideas of an indoctrinated super-soldier raised to be the perfect weapon of someone who didn't care about him as a person at all. Stan Lee's Mandarin basically starts out as sort of Penguin, moves on to sort of being X-23, and then ends as Christopher Columbus, all in the space of a handful of pages.

Gregg Hurwitz is, I believe, the perfect writer to take that brief little origin Stan Lee wrote and expand it into something really interesting.

I recently went back and read the USA Today interview that Brian Bendis gave before taking over Iron Man. He had big plans for Tony. He was going to focus on Tony as "the inventor"...this after Bendis got inspired by watching Iron Man 3 and seeing RDJ-Stark pick up the little screwdriver at the end of the movie. He was also going to give Tony a love interest (something that I really wanted to happen)...he was going to give Iron Man new villains...and make Tony more likable..etc. His goal was to make the comic book version of Iron Man just as important to Marvel Comics as the movie version of Iron Man is to the MCU.

Man, I was bouncing off the walls after reading this interview. Finally! Someone understood. Someone knew what "Tony Stark" needed as a character. I was so excited.

Then...after a few small arcs....Bendis put Tony into a box. What??!! Really? That was his big idea? I don't get it.

I like Riri just fine. I have supported her from the very beginning, but what a big letdown on Tony. No girlfriend (how long did Amara last... 5 issues?) new villains (well those techno-ninjas count, I guess) inventing in his lab (other than 2 pages in the first issue)....Civil War II certainly didn't make him more likable...and worst of all....Rhodey is now dead. Yes, Rhodey, the only comic book character to unconditionally love and care about Tony (well, okay Pepper cares, and Steve Rogers cares, and a few others too), but why take away Rhodey, a character that by his very existence makes Tony seem more likable. After all, if Rhodey loves Tony then Stark can't be all that bad in some fans' eyes).

Let's face it, Tony got tossed aside in favor of Riri. Was this Bendis' plan from the very beginning? If he gave that USA Today interview KNOWING that he was going to toss Tony Stark out after a few arcs, I'd be very disappointed in him.

Anyway, I vote for Warren Ellis as the next writer for Iron Man. Let's see where he would go after Extremis. He could probably write a good Mandarin story too. \:\)

Oh, what might have been...

Posted with Mozilla Firefox 56.0 on Windows 10
Alvaro's Comicboards powered by On Topic™ © 2003-2018 Powermad Software
All the content of these boards Copyright © 1996-2018 by Alvaro Ortiz and Dave Galanter. Software Copyright © 2003-2018 Powermad Software