Amazing Spider-Man Message Board >> View Post
Post By
D. Strange

Member Since: Tue Sep 19, 2017
Posts: 272
In Reply To
Reverend Meteor

Member Since: Sat May 17, 2008
Posts: 9,821
Subj: Re: So, How Was The Second Clone Saga SUPPOSED To End, And What Would Have Happened If It Went As Planned?
Posted: Fri Nov 17, 2017 at 06:55:42 am EST (Viewed 169 times)
Reply Subj: Re: So, How Was The Second Clone Saga SUPPOSED To End, And What Would Have Happened If It Went As Planned?
Posted: Thu Nov 16, 2017 at 12:58:20 pm EST (Viewed 229 times)

Previous Post



    Quote:
    I still would have LOVED to have seen the story play out as planned. It obviously was not meant to go on for two years, and Norman Osborn (And Stromm?)wasn't supposed to return or have anything to do with this. I've read The Life Of Reilly column (More than once, for sure.)that details EVERYTHING about this, but I'm still not sure what the original plan was. Was Aunt May supposed to die (She should have STAYED dead!) in #400? Was Peter supposed to become Spiderman again, or was he supposed to just live a normal life with MJ (Along with their child.)? I know that Ben was going to be Spiderman and have his own book, but were both of them going to be Spidey? Was The Jackal supposed to be brought back, etc. I think that things would have been a LOT different if the original storyline played out. What issue/title was the ending planned for? Their was true potential that obviously got derailed (Probably not for the better.). Thanks.


It really sounds like they never really did agree on how to end it.

I was a little bummed to find out the original intent was to give Peter a baby so Ben could take over because they were sick of writing married Peter. Because the best part of the clone saga to me was the relationship Ben had with Peter and MJ...Peter finally had a blood relative to talk to! And MJ had someone she could talk to ABOUT Peter and her problems. It was great. Peter and MJ always lied to everyone they knew (their friends, family, co-workers) about their problem or they didn't really socialize much with other heroes as friends. Ben was someone to talk to.

But it sounds like the family dynamic Ben brought with him which was the thing I liked best about the clone saga was created by accident. And as much as I love having Ben Reilly back...the dynamic didn't come back with him. MJ and Peter are no longer married. Peter and Ben don't get along. The baby was erased from history. (although with Ben and Aunt May both alive at the same time maybe they can FINALLY meet)


100% agree about Pete and MJ. I always thought that relationship made him better. He had someone to not ONLY talk to, but sometimes help him get out of his own head sometimes.

I love pre-marriage Pete, but there were times he needed that person to tell him he needs to get over himself, and remind him ha had some good things in the world as well.

I thought it was a very natural evolution to bring to the character.

Dan Slott disagrees.