X-Universe >> View Post
·
Post By
The Black Guardian 
Moderator

Member Since: Sat May 17, 2008
Posts: 20,521
In Reply To
emerick-man
Moderator

Member Since: Sat May 17, 2008
Posts: 53,787
Subj: Re: X-Men: Gold #8: PBP...
Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2017 at 02:41:56 pm EDT (Viewed 98 times)
Reply Subj: X-Men: Gold #8: PBP...
Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2017 at 02:08:24 pm EDT (Viewed 123 times)



    Quote:
    p6-7
    Forget exactly why OML & Ro are elsewhere. Did not recall that this happens during the Darkforce Bubble. Not crazy about the (lots of lines but little detail) art around OML & Ro. Remembered afterwards (no narrator box) that the townsfolk feared Kurt as one of the demons - so THEY KILLED HIM! Yes, it was Kurt that saved this interlude and made it mean something. Besides the reminder he has 2 true friends to save him, his amicable perservering dialogue and SHOCKING reveal that he did die. This finally addresses the X-dangler about him being barred from Heaven - and opens that looong overdue intriguing can of worms.

Do not like the idea of Kurt avoiding death because Heaven doesn't want him. Hopefully, that's just his false rationale talking. There are other alternatives to Heaven, after all.


    Quote:
    p8
    Namedropping Tony Stark seems to be a Marvel must. A new 'kryptonite' for Kitty. Kitty taking charge like a real leader.

Did not like this. Electricity is electricity, regardless of whether it's biological or technological. It's already established that Kitty can hurt bioelectrical currents just like electronics.


    Quote:
    p9
    Piotr/Santo banter leads to a good character moment for Piotr. Too bad Dust wasn't given the moment to share some of Rockslide's facetime (even though he deserves as much as he can get). More dislikable (lots of lines but little detail) art moments with the crowd of kids and unconvincing numbers at The Mansion. Not even one Easter Egg cameo. Probably because many of the Handbook kids could have offered logical help of some kind.

Yeah.


    Quote:
    p10-11
    Interlude in Russia. Could've been 1 page. No idenifying the pair - so why care ("Anatoly" is like "John Smith"). Clearly it's The (boringly recyclable) Hand's contribution of an (equally recyclable) way to bring back anyone from the dead, whenever. REMIND ME: when did Omega Red die last?

Wolverine Origins, circa #40. His soul later showed up when Logan went to Hell.


    Quote:
    p12-15
    Nod to Shadowcat persona/skills is a continuity friendly. Power Dampener is precidented 'kryptonite' which is okay - No Prize might be X-Cutioner has a limited supply and is only using one now because, uhh, he's desperate? Pixie scores a cameo. Uhh, why doesn't she magick something up or away? The scenario makes for a good hand to hand sequence for Kitty. Could've been 1 (or 2) page less. Hmmph, only Kitty seems to have the knack for knocking off that faceplate of his.

Yeah, I wouldn't think Pixie could be so easily captured. I think they just wanted to use a popular student. And she didn't even say anything. *sigh* Remember when she used to be the motormouth student? There are better choices, imo.


    Quote:
    p1 6-17
    Kitty/x-Cutioner conversation face-off was excellent.

Indeed.


    Quote:
    18
    Great telegraphed calvary moment and gunshot fate. So much for 'spider-sense' subconsciously turning Organic Steel theory.

Eh. I'm with Santo. This was stupid-crazy, but true Piotr.


    Quote:
    19
    SUPER surprise Santo backup calvary moment and one-liner! \:\) PUT ROCKSLIDE ON THE TEAM! (But not so much the every molecule is alive Sandman-like version.)

WOOHOO! ROCK ON SANTO!

Yes, it should be remembered that none of his rock is alive. It's just normal rock surrounding a psionic energy being. And no one should forget he isn't just limited to rock.


    Quote:
    20
    Liked the last page epilogue. It reminds us about the S.E. crossover element but more importantly confirms that crossover is done in this title. Implies spoilers for these characters seen. It states DAYS LATER (even though that sounds like total hyperbole of how long it lasted) and INFERS that X-men kept the bad guy prisoner for some time while USA was in unrest. Great low key last panel and next plot set up with the topical USA focus on deportations. It might be interesting to see how everyone deals with only being allowed true Americans on the Central Park X-men.

Yeah, meanwhile over in the real SE story, the dome was over NYC for weeks.


    Quote:
    Letters Page
    Wow - the chapter keeps giving: So this Prestige power up and Colossus power down is 'a thing' in development. Interesting. Also the Russian threat, Kurt 'died', there's S.E. fall out coming, Kitty (re)learned a lesson or two, Santo rocked... If the art were a bit better than the rating would be a bit better than 'quite the good closing chapter'. HOW DO YOU RATE IT?

Without a doubt the best issue of this series so far, aside from the nits above.


Posted with Mozilla Firefox 54.0 on Windows 10
Alvaro's Comicboards powered by On Topic™ © 2003-2017 Powermad Software
All the content of these boards Copyright © 1996-2017 by Alvaro Ortiz and Dave Galanter. Software Copyright © 2003-2017 Powermad Software