X-Universe >> View Post
·
Post By
America's Captain 
Maintainer

Location: Bayville New Jersey
Member Since: Mon Aug 06, 2012
Posts: 9,532
In Reply To
emerick-man
Moderator

Member Since: Sat May 17, 2008
Posts: 53,833
Subj: Re: X-Men: Gold #8: PBP...
Posted: Fri Jul 21, 2017 at 09:20:56 am EDT (Viewed 71 times)
Reply Subj: X-Men: Gold #8: PBP...
Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2017 at 02:08:24 pm EDT (Viewed 126 times)



    Quote:
    X-Men Gold 008 (2017)



    Quote:
    p1
    Great cliffhanger followup presentation and gunshot fate.



    Quote:
    p2
    Easily dodging machine gun fire here is a bit too much trope but... understandable superhero action intention. Bit of a fail. Hmm, wonder if his bullets would've even worked on Organic Steel.


I hate it when heroes dodge machine gun fire. I can almost accept it when Kitty does it, due to her virtual lifetime of martial arts training bestowed by Ogun, but Peter dodging machine gun fire is plain ridiculous and actually irritating to me.


    Quote:
    p6-7
    Forget exactly why OML & Ro are elsewhere. Did not recall that this happens during the Darkforce Bubble. Not crazy about the (lots of lines but little detail) art around OML & Ro. Remembered afterwards (no narrator box) that the townsfolk feared Kurt as one of the demons - so THEY KILLED HIM! Yes, it was Kurt that saved this interlude and made it mean something. Besides the reminder he has 2 true friends to save him, his amicable perservering dialogue and SHOCKING reveal that he did die. This finally addresses the X-dangler about him being barred from Heaven - and opens that looong overdue intriguing can of worms.


Without a doubt the most important few panels in the issue. The religious story line is very unique to Nightcrawler and therefore (if followed up on) will be a welcome excursion for us Nightcrawler fans.


    Quote:
    p9
    Piotr/Santo banter leads to a good character moment for Piotr. Too bad Dust wasn't given the moment to share some of Rockslide's facetime (even though he deserves as much as he can get). More dislikable (lots of lines but little detail) art moments with the crowd of kids and unconvincing numbers at The Mansion. Not even one Easter Egg cameo. Probably because many of the Handbook kids could have offered logical help of some kind.


"I am not crazy. I am Russian!"

That was a very Russian thing to say and I love it when Peter says such things.

And yes, the art this issue was sub-par. I really wish the original artist on this book had resisted the urge to be a dork. His art was some of the best I've ever seen.


    Quote:
    p10-11
    Interlude in Russia. Could've been 1 page. No idenifying the pair - so why care ("Anatoly" is like "John Smith"). Clearly it's The (boringly recyclable) Hand's contribution of an (equally recyclable) way to bring back anyone from the dead, whenever. REMIND ME: when did Omega Red die last?


I don't know the answer but I guess this interlude will involve Peter in some way eventually. Maybe Kitty too. Russians and Ninjas seem right up this duo's alley.


    Quote:
    p12-15
    Nod to Shadowcat persona/skills is continuity friendly. Power Dampener is precidented 'kryptonite' which is okay - No Prize might be X-Cutioner has a limited supply and is only using one now because, uhh, he's desperate? Pixie scores a cameo. Uhh, why doesn't she magick something up or away? The scenario makes for a good hand to hand sequence for Kitty. Could've been 1 (or 2) page less. Hmmph, only Kitty seems to have the knack for knocking off that faceplate of his.


I hated when the faceplate came off. It really felt like the writer was thinking, "OK we're pretty much done now - the bad guy has to lose so we can move on."


    Quote:
    18
    Great telegraphed calvary moment and gunshot fate. So much for 'spider-sense' subconsciously turning Organic Steel theory.


Blocking a bullet with your own body isn't crazy - it's Russian!


    Quote:
    19
    SUPER surprise Santo backup calvary moment and one-liner! \:\) PUT ROCKSLIDE ON THE TEAM! (But not so much the every molecule is alive Sandman-like version.)


Count me in as a vote for Rockslide's permanent team membership.


    Quote:
    20
    Liked the last page epilogue. It reminds us about the S.E. crossover element but more importantly confirms that crossover is done in this title. Implies spoilers for these characters seen. It states DAYS LATER (even though that sounds like total hyperbole of how long it lasted) and INFERS that X-men kept the bad guy prisoner for some time while USA was in unrest. Great low key last panel and next plot set up with the topical USA focus on deportations. It might be interesting to see how everyone deals with only being allowed true Americans on the Central Park X-men.


Unfortunately I've encountered the government versus heroes story line once too often. Stan Lee practically patented it. But if it gets the team out of Central Park - the absolute stupidest place they could be - I guess I'm cool with it.


    Quote:
    If the art were a bit better then the rating would be a bit better than 'quite the good closing chapter'. HOW DO YOU RATE IT?


6 out of 10 - and would have been lower if not for the Nightcrawler and Russia interludes and what they portend.






Posted with Google Chrome 59.0.3071.115 on Windows 10
Alvaro's Comicboards powered by On Topic™ © 2003-2017 Powermad Software
All the content of these boards Copyright © 1996-2017 by Alvaro Ortiz and Dave Galanter. Software Copyright © 2003-2017 Powermad Software