X-Universe >> View Post
·
Post By
The Black Guardian 
Moderator

Member Since: Sat May 17, 2008
Posts: 21,202
In Reply To
emerick-man
Moderator

Member Since: Sat May 17, 2008
Posts: 54,635
Subj: Re: X-Men Blue #9: Hot Mess PBP...
Posted: Thu Aug 17, 2017 at 10:05:52 am EDT (Viewed 124 times)
Reply Subj: X-Men Blue #9: Hot Mess PBP...
Posted: Wed Aug 16, 2017 at 01:44:08 pm EDT (Viewed 157 times)



    Quote:
    X-Men: Blue 009 (2017)



    Quote:
    Ish 7 ended with so much potential but sadly none of those curiousities had proper exposition in the next issue. Ish 8 dropped the ball but did offer the return of Danger and Polaris and intriguing implications there. Unfortunately, this ish -with the grabber cover- was ruined with ZERO explanation or backstory details of HOW THE HECK those two got to be working with Magneto. That, and the rest of the title team's PASSING MARKS escape was just a hot MESS. Let's nitpick page by page...



    Quote:
    Xorn and Emma negotiated the treaty for New Tian?! It's so good to learn important details so belatedly and in the pseudo-canon Recap Page after the fact. NOT. We still haven't clearly been told how Stevil Rogers deal with Magneto to retire was done in absense of the declared King Xorn. And what degree of certainty Magneto had that his hated Emma was absolutely in the equation. The only apparent chronological indicator of this tale to the S.E.Event is that the Cosmic Cube Shard in it has not been given to HydraCap yet. Annoyingly non-footnoted as usual.



    Quote:
    Jean's narrative about the "RESCUE MISSION" felt SLOPPY reading as technically she is referring to 1 of the 2 rescue missions. The botched one to save the dissidents and the clumsiness solution to save the later captured O5. Plus, she seemingly claims to know a direct confrontation with Emma was expected. And yet, it did not feel that Magneto categorically confirmed it was her running the country (or was alive), right?



    Quote:
    The perfectly placed splash page magnetic blast cancelling out a cosmic blast may have mesmerized me in bygone years but now it just seems illogical trope. The overall art was plain average EXCEPT all the special f/x showing the Lorna's magnetism was ugly. (And Alex has shown concentric circles since the beginning -fine- but have they ever seemed like randomly placed little bubble bath swaths before?) As their fight progresses the clashing f/x look even... sillier.

Havok's looked like that before. Only real difference is that the circles are filled in.


    Quote:
    Magneto may have told more about Emma to the kids than it appeared but he also openly shared the fact that Pietro and Wanda were not his kids?!

He's probably so glad he brags about it.


    Quote:
    Polaris calling Jimmy by name was awkward implied recognition for this reader, if not Jimmy too.

She's the teacher.


    Quote:
    Jean does okay against Hellfire Goons but considering her title's training (before or after this) and her basic skill levels, Jimmy should have been able to sit that one out.

Well, sure, but why?


    Quote:
    PLEASE tell me that was not Beast's magick that finally got their collars off. It was Jean, somehow seeing thru his mutant eyes the dampening collars -not dampening his ability to psi reply- and then she snapped them open from a remote location with her always fluctuating power level. Which isn't necessarily much better an option. The f/x were ugly again and source unclear.

It seemed clear to me that it was Jeen [sic] (not Beast's magic) that got the collars off. There was no mention at all of Beast magicking them off. Pink usually means telekinesis. She was able to locate them telepathically to rescue them, so not a big deal to tk their collars.


    Quote:
    Maybe instead of the common 'brother from another mother' cry, Jean could have been more appropriate with her bland rallying cry to save Scott by saying 'save cyke from his ex-wife from another life'. ;\)

Well, Emma was never his wife. That must really tick her off.


    Quote:
    OH, C'MON NOW, Polaris! Now, you're bragging to be better than Magneto?! Sheesh.

Not that outlandish a claim, and not the craziest thing Lorna's ever said. She did get an amp after the Apocalypse thing. And Magneto has been long-plagued with power problems, whereas she has not. It's something that maybe should be tested, and I might not place my money on Our Lord.


    Quote:
    Another flaw with the average art is the scene transitions during the fights. First their in Briar's room then Scott's blasting them in the hallway? First, there's a big fight in the courtyard, then Polaris has to travel to find Danger?

Well, yeah, there were multiple fights in multiple places. Lorna was never fighting in the same place as Danger.


    Quote:
    The perfectly placed splash page of Cyke's arrival also ruined by ugly drawing of his optic f/x.

It was in the style of Old Scott's still-not-explained wacky post-Phoenix blasts. It shouldn't be coming from Tyke.


    Quote:
    Beast can magick on the run now?! SHEEEEEEEEEEESH!

Shouldn't matter.


    Quote:
    As ugly as the optic f/x were even worse was the implied damage being done by them after multiple hits on the O5. It's ridiculous (cliche) that his blasts were bascially all shrugged off by those of good heart.

Always has been, really. His blats have always been powered by plot.


    Quote:
    Maybe it would be good to tell readers exactly what Xorn's power is doing rather than more ugly f/x as explanation.

Yes.


    Quote:
    At first seeing future versions of Cyke being Young Cyke's mental block was odd but then it was a decent organic explanation and warped plan of poor losing-it Emma trying to rewrite him. The only good plot point to remember.

Indeed. How screwed up is that?! Emma's trying to turn a probably not legal kid into her sig.other. Yikes. Although I'm kinda confused. They might have retconned Scott into being 18 at the beginning of X-Men now. I know they've at least tried to do this (the most recent Cyke Origin one-shot).


    Quote:
    Remind me who is that big guy with Toad and Firestar (where's HIS I.D. box, eh)? And WHY give Firestar new costume design???? Yuck. Maybe the o5 should have joked inappropriately with the New Tian Strikeforce before because in this rematch they win - and the bad guys had some added Hellfire Goons this time. *koff*

"Big Guy" is Mondo, formerly of old-school Generation X. He's basically a mutant Absorbing Man. I'm more pissed off that Firestar is even working with Emma than what she's wearing, even if she's being mind controlled.


    Quote:
    nb. Magneto only has one Blackbird. (And he went to a lot of trouble to sneak/fit one into the Madripoor Danger Room - since Ish 1??)



    Quote:
    OH FER THE LUVVA... So, this was the forced lame plot device to give this Jean/Scott couple the same cool psychic bond that Old Jean/Scott had. SHEEEEEEEEEEESH! Another gift of the (temporary?) Cosmic Cube shattering.

Yes. The dreaded return of the psi-link. However, I like that it was Emma that caused this. Irony!


    Quote:
    OH BROTHER. It's all a Back to School set up? A Return to Cashing in on the Classics? If it ain't broke, don't fix it but if it gets broke then old school is better than upgrade. Lorna will be the hot teacher, Danger, the bookish prudebot? Briar, the flatscan teacher that harshes on you? Bah.

It's like Bunn is having ADHD. Several issues, no resolution, aaand... status quo change.

I guess maybe no one really knows what to do with these characters.


    Quote:
    Mags and Cap have a weak but necessary debate about their positions in S.E. Not that it matters at this point in the main Event but it does offer -very wanting- rationale why mutants weren't more involved fro the whole thing.



    Quote:
    Waitaminnit! So, is Emma clumsily confirming that the previously destroyed Island of Utopia is indeed the Capital City of New Tian and therefore must be a part of the part of California the Mutants' Country is? How can you further ruin a ruined Atlantean Spire? Atlantis is such an abused concept of the MU for ages now. Sheesh.

It's either the capital or just part of it.

My opinion Atlantis has been ruined since they re-sunk it (remember when it resurfaced back in the 90s). However, I can see the argument that raising it was its ruination.


    Quote:
    Enter: A truly shocking and intriguing reveal to try and get readers to forget the story failing for 19 pages... BASTION and MISS SINISTER teaming with EMMA and ALEX?!

Yeah. Miss Sinister, I can sorta get. Bastion?! Never mind that Bastion's new M.O. makes no logical sense.


Posted with Mozilla Firefox 54.0 on Windows 10
Alvaro's Comicboards powered by On Topic™ © 2003-2017 Powermad Software
All the content of these boards Copyright © 1996-2017 by Alvaro Ortiz and Dave Galanter. Software Copyright © 2003-2017 Powermad Software