Comic Battle >> View Thread

Author
zvelf


Member Since: Sat May 17, 2008


I did not include fanboy votes just for Thor because those voters did not bother to participate in the rest of the match-ups, violating the spirit of the game.

Round 2 results:

Group 1:
Hope Summers d. Thor 3-3, but Hope wins "last man standing" group fight 3-2
Magneto    d. Captain Britain and Tigra 6-0
Storm d. Protector 5-1
Cable d. Valkyrie 4-2

Group 2:
Hulk d. Nightcrawler (Age of Apocalypse) 6-0
She-Hulk d. Frenzy 5-1
Giant Man (Henry Pym) and Quake    d. Cannonball 4-2
Deadpool d. Prince of Orphans 5-1

Group 3:
Iron Man d. Warpath 6-0
War Machine d. Shadowcat 4-2
Vision d. Angel 6-0
Captain America d. Longshot 5-1

Group 4:
Emma Frost d. Ms. Marvel 5-1
Spider-Man d. Psylocke 4-2
Wolverine d. Spider-Woman 5-1
Black Widow and Hawkeye    d. Shatterstar 5-1

The rules: All characters are in their current forms in the comics. The fights take place in an evacuated New York City. Combatants start off 20 yards apart. No battlefield removal allowed. Fight ends when one opponent is unconscious or immobilized in a way from which the character cannot escape. 4 characters from each team make 1 group. Tell me who wins the 4 individual match-ups in each group and then tell me who’s left standing as the winners of the individual match-ups fight one another in their group.

Group 1:
Hulk vs. Magneto
Iron Man vs. Hope Summers (Hope can copy the powers of Magneto, Cable, and Storm here)
Vision vs. Cable
War Machine vs. Storm

Group 2:
Spider-Man, Captain America, Giant Man (Pym), and Quake vs. Emma Frost
She-Hulk vs. Wolverine
Black Widow and Hawkeye vs. Deadpool





How to make an entrance: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PfMiOlIUGQw
Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 7 on Windows XP
MysetryMan





    Quote:
    I did not include fanboy votes just for Thor because those voters did not bother to participate in the rest of the match-ups, violating the spirit of the game.



    Quote:
    Round 2 results:



    Quote:
    Group 1:
    Hope Summers d. Thor 3-3, but Hope wins "last man standing" group fight 3-2
    Magneto    d. Captain Britain and Tigra 6-0
    Storm d. Protector 5-1
    Cable d. Valkyrie 4-2



    Quote:
    Group 2:
    Hulk d. Nightcrawler (Age of Apocalypse) 6-0
    She-Hulk d. Frenzy 5-1
    Giant Man (Henry Pym) and Quake    d. Cannonball 4-2
    Deadpool d. Prince of Orphans 5-1



    Quote:
    Group 3:
    Iron Man d. Warpath 6-0
    War Machine d. Shadowcat 4-2
    Vision d. Angel 6-0
    Captain America d. Longshot 5-1



    Quote:
    Group 4:
    Emma Frost d. Ms. Marvel 5-1
    Spider-Man d. Psylocke 4-2
    Wolverine d. Spider-Woman 5-1
    Black Widow and Hawkeye    d. Shatterstar 5-1



    Quote:
    The rules: All characters are in their current forms in the comics. The fights take place in an evacuated New York City. Combatants start off 20 yards apart. No battlefield removal allowed. Fight ends when one opponent is unconscious or immobilized in a way from which the character cannot escape. 4 characters from each team make 1 group. Tell me who wins the 4 individual match-ups in each group and then tell me who’s left standing as the winners of the individual match-ups fight one another in their group.



    Quote:
    Group 1:
    Hulk vs. Magneto
    Iron Man vs. Hope Summers (Hope can copy the powers of Magneto, Cable, and Storm here)
    Vision vs. Cable
    War Machine vs. Storm


Mags but it takes a long time

Huh what? Fulle powered Mags Cable and Storm? That seems unfair like 3 on 1...does Tony get nanites then too? He has those currently. Is hope registered? If so he wins then anyways..otherwise just hand the whole thing to Hope if she gets full powered versions of any x-man around.
If she only gets a portion of their powers she is also in trouble as Tony has specific psychic and Magneto defenses. And Storm would just power him up with lightning.

Vision takes Cable

WMachine takes Storm

Hope or the Avengers if she isnt being treated at cosmic levels.


    Quote:
    Group 2:
    Spider-Man, Captain America, Giant Man (Pym), and Quake vs. Emma Frost
    She-Hulk vs. Wolverine
    Black Widow and Hawkeye vs. Deadpool


All 4 against Emma? Seems unfair...many of these have amazing will power to resist Emma and she dare not go Diamond here. If she can really just turn them off she wins though 3 of these Avengers have top-level wills.

Shulk > Wolvie

Deadpool > than these 2

Depends on how first matchup goes. If Emma wins Shulkie is pwnd. If she loses, Deadpool is.


Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 7 on Windows XP
Bk Ray

Moderator

Member Since: Sat May 17, 2008
Posts: 8,929



Group 1:
Hulk vs. Magneto
Current Magneto edges a very tough fight.
Iron Man vs. Hope Summers (Hope can copy the powers of Magneto, Cable, and Storm here)
Complete mismatch. Hope wins.
Vision vs. Cable
Good fight. Edge Vision.
War Machine vs. Storm
Edge War Machine.
Magneto and Hope beat War Machine and Vision.

Group 2:
Spider-Man, Captain America, Giant Man (Pym), and Quake vs. Emma Frost
Emma loses to this team.
She-Hulk vs. Wolverine
She Hulk wins.
Black Widow and Hawkeye vs. Deadpool
Deadpool squeaks a win.
Deadpool gets hurt bad by the remaining Avengers.








Moderator: Star Trek Board ''He stood alone at Gjallerbru... and that answer is enough.''
Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 7 5.0; on Windows 7
wyld0007





    Quote:
    Group 1:
    Hulk vs. Magneto

    - Hulk wins eventually i think. 6/10 - i see the Hulk just enduring the pain and assault from Mags to get close and plow through Mags' shields to take the win.

    Iron Man vs. Hope Summers (Hope can copy the powers of Magneto, Cable, and Storm here)

    - Hope if she's capable of the things everyone else is saying about her.

    Vision vs. Cable

    - Vision

    War Machine vs. Storm


- War Machine

i think Hulk is the last man standing after Hope takes some damage but still takes out Vision and War Machine before going down.


    Quote:
    Group 2:
    Spider-Man, Captain America, Giant Man (Pym), and Quake vs. Emma Frost

    - the team is just too much for Emma

    She-Hulk vs. Wolverine

    - Wolverine keeps up with the Hulk, i think he can Cut & Gut Jenny for the win.

    Black Widow and Hawkeye vs. Deadpool

    - Deadpools healing is off the charts, but i think the duo can tie him up for the win.


Spider-Man, Captain America, Giant-Man (Pym), Quake, Black Widow and Hawkeye are just WAAAY too much for Wolverine. he might take a couple out, but he can't win.


Posted with Mozilla Firefox 10.0 on Windows 7
Concordant





Group 1:
Hulk vs. Magneto
- I think Hulk's HF will be put to the test but ultimately will be what allows him to stay in the game long enough to win here.

Iron Man vs. Hope Summers (Hope can copy the powers of Magneto, Cable, and Storm here)
- IM is out-powered here but Hope lacks experience which a sneaky Tony can capitalize on. Unfortunately, not for the majority. So Hope takes this one.

Vision vs. Cable
- Vision. Vision going intangible and solidifying his hand in Nate's head should be enough to disrupt him and get the win.

War Machine vs. Storm
- Since it's just one-on-one I think War Machine has this one pretty easily. He should be resilient enough to weather a few lightning bolts and really... all it should take is one repulsor blast to take her down.

- With Magneto, Storm and Cable down... Hope has no hope. Hulk is the last man standing.

Group 2:
Spider-Man, Captain America, Giant Man (Pym), and Quake vs. Emma Frost
- A bit one-sided here. Emma could mess with a couple of them maybe with her TP, but in the end she'll be overwhelmed. Diamond form isn't going to help but delay the inevitable.

She-Hulk vs. Wolverine
- She-Hulk. In an abandoned New York she just knocks over a building on top of him. But if she decided to just slug it out, she'd lose.

Black Widow and Hawkeye vs. Deadpool
- Wade takes out Widow but then gets tagged by an explosive arrow by Hawkeye which takes Pool out long enough to secure the win.

- Last man standing - Spidey. I think most will be focused on taking She-Hulk out that she'll eventually go down and Pete will be the guy at the end moping up.


C.





Posted with Mozilla Firefox 9.0.1 on Windows 7
Bk Ray

Moderator

Member Since: Sat May 17, 2008
Posts: 8,929




    Quote:

    Group 1:
    Hulk vs. Magneto
    Current Magneto edges a very tough fight.
    Iron Man vs. Hope Summers (Hope can copy the powers of Magneto, Cable, and Storm here)
    Complete mismatch. Hope wins.
    Vision vs. Cable
    Good fight. Edge Vision.
    War Machine vs. Storm
    Edge War Machine.
    Magneto and Hope beat War Machine and Vision.

In a free for all Hope wins handily.


    Quote:
    Group 2:
    Spider-Man, Captain America, Giant Man (Pym), and Quake vs. Emma Frost
    Emma loses to this team.
    She-Hulk vs. Wolverine
    She Hulk wins.
    Black Widow and Hawkeye vs. Deadpool
    Deadpool squeaks a win.
    Deadpool gets hurt bad by the remaining Avengers.



    Quote:


In a free for all She Hulk wins.





Moderator: Star Trek Board ''He stood alone at Gjallerbru... and that answer is enough.''
Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 7 5.0; on Windows 7
THUNDERER!!!




Fact is it was 3-3 dont know WTH the last man standing thing is, oh well enjoy your tourney, I did'nt really play by the rules so I assumed my vote would'nt count, although it was far from a fan based vote, I truly feel Thor would beat hope, but whatever, the fact that im a Thor fan I get sterotyped as bias, when I have always benn anything but. Maby I should have suplied my reasons. So it my fault.


Posted with Apple Safari 4.0 on Linux
emerick-man

Moderator

Member Since: Sat May 17, 2008



    Quote:
    I did not include fanboy votes just for Thor because those voters did not bother to participate in the rest of the match-ups, violating the spirit of the game.



    Quote:
    Round 2 results:



    Quote:
    Group 1:
    Hope Summers d. Thor 3-3, but Hope wins "last man standing" group fight 3-2
    Magneto    d. Captain Britain and Tigra 6-0
    Storm d. Protector 5-1
    Cable d. Valkyrie 4-2



    Quote:
    Group 2:
    Hulk d. Nightcrawler (Age of Apocalypse) 6-0
    She-Hulk d. Frenzy 5-1
    Giant Man (Henry Pym) and Quake    d. Cannonball 4-2
    Deadpool d. Prince of Orphans 5-1



    Quote:
    Group 3:
    Iron Man d. Warpath 6-0
    War Machine d. Shadowcat 4-2
    Vision d. Angel 6-0
    Captain America d. Longshot 5-1



    Quote:
    Group 4:
    Emma Frost d. Ms. Marvel 5-1
    Spider-Man d. Psylocke 4-2
    Wolverine d. Spider-Woman 5-1
    Black Widow and Hawkeye    d. Shatterstar 5-1



    Quote:
    The rules: All characters are in their current forms in the comics. The fights take place in an evacuated New York City. Combatants start off 20 yards apart. No battlefield removal allowed. Fight ends when one opponent is unconscious or immobilized in a way from which the character cannot escape. 4 characters from each team make 1 group. Tell me who wins the 4 individual match-ups in each group and then tell me who’s left standing as the winners of the individual match-ups fight one another in their group.



    Quote:
    Group 1:
    Hulk
    Iron Man
    Cable
    Storm

last woman STORM


    Quote:
    Group 2:
    Spider-Man, Captain America, Giant Man (Pym), and Quake
    Black Widow and Hawkeye

last man GIANT MAN


THOR615

Resolving to move on...






I miss you, Dan. I miss you, Dad. I miss you, Dan.
I miss you, Dad & Dan. I miss you Dad and Dan. Support Cancer Research.
Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 7 on Windows Vista
Ragnarok






    Quote:
    Group 1:
    Hulk vs. Magneto
    Iron Man vs. Hope Summers (Hope can copy the powers of Magneto, Cable, and Storm here)
    Vision vs. Cable
    War Machine vs. Storm


Magneto
Hope I guess. Seems she is very fortunately paired with the best muties each round.
Vision
War Machine

Mags and Hope


    Quote:
    Group 2:
    Spider-Man, Captain America, Giant Man (Pym), and Quake vs. Emma Frost
    She-Hulk vs. Wolverine
    Black Widow and Hawkeye vs. Deadpool


Emma
Wolverine
Deadpool


Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 7 5.0; on Windows 7
RANDOM




Group 1:
Hulk vs. Magneto

Hulk goes BOOM! magento is completely the wrong opponent for th Hulk and wins (I'm assuming this isn't I can beat all and every opponent in 1 panel uber Hulk)

Iron Man vs. Hope Summers (Hope can copy the powers of Magneto, Cable, and Storm here)

Hope wins (although Ironman has a better shot than most)

Vision vs. Cable

Depends on how much TK Cable has at the moment. best bet Vision wins.

War Machine vs. Storm

Close - I'll edge Storm.

Vision somehow takes down Hope - sucker phased fist from behind maybe.

That being said Magneto and Storm are still standing at the end.

Group 2:
Spider-Man, Captain America, Giant Man (Pym), and Quake vs. Emma Frost

Any given sunday matchup. She couls psi wipe them all and win instantly, alternatively they could dogpile her. I'll say she takes them all out except Cap who lands a lucky/skillful ricochet shield shot.

She-Hulk vs. Wolverine

Good fight. Could go either way but I'll give the nod to Jen.

Black Widow and Hawkeye vs. Deadpool

He'd beat either 1 v 1 but would he beat the double team? I'm going to say yes Deadpool wins.


Deadpool takes down a hurting Cap but is then pwned by Jen.




Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 8 4.0; on Windows 7
RANDOM




i can't say for a fact that Hope isn'r registered but I cannot see any possible reason why she would be. She was only bor during the Messia complex and since then has either been under the protection of Cable or Scott and neither of them are right keen on registration.

As for how much of their powers she gets, she gets a boosted version of their power (what they are truly capapble of after evolution). So she's more powerful than any of them with their own powers. That is assuming she hasn't been powered down. \:\-


Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 8 4.0; on Windows 7
RANDOM




i'd have to agree about Hope and if she'd been teamed up with Cyclops, Wolverine and Nightcrawler I couldn't have picked her over Thor last round. That being said Cyclops would put her with the uber muties wouldn't he?


Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 8 4.0; on Windows 7
MjolnirsPower


Member Since: Sat May 17, 2008
Posts: 2,362






"Pay Homage to the Might of Thor, Son of Odin!"- Odin
Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 5.0 on Windows 7
THUNDERER!!!




To give two shzzzts about, but let em have they're fun, I should have played by the rules, We both Know Thor would probably beat the crap outta any of those X-Teams, LOL!!! its cool man.


Posted with Sony Playstation 3
THUNDERER!!!




I can see why you gave it to her though as a few others did give rather good arguments for her, although good I seriously doubt would actually happen. but thats me.


Posted with Sony Playstation 3
THUNDERER!!!






Posted with Sony Playstation 3
THUNDERER!!!






Posted with Sony Playstation 3
THUNDERER!!!




Yeah I know it's a bit late, but i'm guessing this may have changed things alot sooner, Cyttorak is not a mutant entity and niether is the power he bestows.


Posted with Sony Playstation 3
THUNDERER!!!






Posted with Sony Playstation 3
RANDOM




unless her powerset has been watered down she has all powers at a boosted level which would make her pretty dang strong. I'd say a boosted Colossus would be closish to Thor in strength and durability 9depending how much he was boosted). She definitely shouldn't got the cytorrak powers though. \:\-d


Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 5.0 on Windows 7
zvelf


Member Since: Sat May 17, 2008



    Quote:
    Group 1:
    Hulk vs. Magneto
    Iron Man vs. Hope Summers (Hope can copy the powers of Magneto, Cable, and Storm here)
    Vision vs. Cable
    War Machine vs. Storm


In a different environment, Hulk could win, but Magneto could throw virtually the entire city at Hulk. Hulk loses badly. Other winners are Hope, Vision, and War Machine.


    Quote:
    Group 2:
    Spider-Man, Captain America, Giant Man (Pym), and Quake vs. Emma Frost
    She-Hulk vs. Wolverine
    Black Widow and Hawkeye vs. Deadpool


Emma has shown little trouble psi-blasting or mind controlling even strong willed folk like Wolverine, but it's 50/50 between Emma and the Avengers depending on who hits first between Emma and Quake. I'll give Emma the nod. Other winners are Wolverine and Widow/Hawkeye. Emma and Wolverine are left standing.





How to make an entrance: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PfMiOlIUGQw
Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 7 on Windows XP
Fifthchild


Member Since: Sat May 17, 2008
Posts: 9,474



I believe Thor is one of zvelfs favourites if not his favourite character.





His Holiness The Pope
The Church of Hulk
St Jones Church, New Mexico
Posted with Google Chrome 16.0.912.63 on MacOS X
Liam Gallagher's Unibrow


Location: Mega-City One
Member Since: Sat May 17, 2008




    Quote:
    Emma has shown little trouble psi-blasting or mind controlling even strong willed folk like Wolverine


That's pretty variable to be fair though. To use your example, I recall Wolverine literally no-selling Emma's psi even when she believed Cyclops' life depended on it in at least one instance...




Cheers.






Chancellor Liam, Dean of the Forgotten Green Academy of Gamma Sciences
"Hulk would have to be in a life or death struggle for a good 25+ years to BEGIN to start to surpass [Thor]." - MjolnirsPower
I Fought the Law and the Law Won... A Judge Dredd Respect Thread
http://herochat.com/index.php?topic=2435.0
(work in progress)
Posted with Google Chrome 16.0.912.75 on Windows Vista
zvelf


Member Since: Sat May 17, 2008



    Quote:


      Quote:
      Emma has shown little trouble psi-blasting or mind controlling even strong willed folk like Wolverine



    Quote:
    That's pretty variable to be fair though. To use your example, I recall Wolverine literally no-selling Emma's psi even when she believed Cyclops' life depended on it in at least one instance...


I haven't seen that issue, but Wolverine and Beast were fighting in an issue not too long ago, and Emma mind-controlled both and made them bow to each other. And in their very first meeting, Emma downed Wolverine, Storm, and Colossus at the same time with one psi-blast with the narration stating the three X-Men had specific psi-resistance training and the White Queen still beat them without great effort.





How to make an entrance: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PfMiOlIUGQw
Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 7 on Windows XP

Alvaro's Comicboards powered by On Topic™ © 2003-2022 Powermad Software