Justice League of America >> View Thread

Author
JRC




I was very disappointed with the Meltzer's run in this title. And the McDuffye's work is not better so far...


Posted with Mozilla Firefox 2.0.0.11 on Windows XP
Racer Cool




> I was very disappointed with the Meltzer's run in this title. And the McDuffye's work is not better so far...

I have to disagree with you. Both Meltzer and McDuffie's runs are pretty good but they can't beat Grant Morrison's theratical run and the comedic antics of the Giffen/DeMatteis run.

The worst volume is the period of the JLDetroit era. DC made a bad decision to transform the World's Greatest Super-Heroes into a poor man's DC version of the X-Men. I left the series when Superman, Wonder Woman and Flash called it quits.

The second worst is the period post-Death of Superman. All three Justice League books at the time were splintered and lacked focus. Got even worse post-Zero Hour. I left the series after Dan Jurgen's run.

I'm satisified. Although, Meltzer's JLA reads way better as a graphic novel than a monthly comicbook series.


Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 6 on Windows XP
Echo




> > I was very disappointed with the Meltzer's run in this title. And the McDuffye's work is not better so far...
>
> I have to disagree with you. Both Meltzer and McDuffie's runs are pretty good but they can't beat Grant Morrison's theratical run and the comedic antics of the Giffen/DeMatteis run.


I have to agree that Morrison's run was fun and the best i ever read, McDuffie's run just started so i am waiting patiently to see what he does with the team and the cross overs are not helping me. Meltzer run is a waste of time. Nothing interesting happened.


> I'm satisified. Although, Meltzer's JLA reads way better as a graphic novel than a monthly comicbook series.

That's why he should stick to writing books not COMIC books! I buy comic books not Books!

Echo




Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 7 on Windows XP
J.H




> I was very disappointed with the Meltzer's run in this title. And the McDuffye's work is not better so far...

Meltzer wrote the worst JLA story ever in Identity Crisis. His arc in this volume pointless and long winded. Like all of of his novels.

He ruined so many characters.


Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 7 on Windows XP
Hellstone




...Meltzer did a really good job. Maybe a bit anti-climactic (as all of his comics have been so far), but well-written with good adventure and good characterization.

MacDuffie on the other hand... I'm not sure I can even call his work "stories". Things just happen and don't make sense. This may be the worst JLA since the mid 90s or so. And that's saying a lot.


/ola


Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 6 on Windows XP
Chris




> > I was very disappointed with the Meltzer's run in this title. And the McDuffye's work is not better so far...
>
> I have to disagree with you. Both Meltzer and McDuffie's runs are pretty good but they can't beat Grant Morrison's theratical run and the comedic antics of the Giffen/DeMatteis run.
>
> The worst volume is the period of the JLDetroit era. DC made a bad decision to transform the World's Greatest Super-Heroes into a poor man's DC version of the X-Men. I left the series when Superman, Wonder Woman and Flash called it quits.
>
> The second worst is the period post-Death of Superman. All three Justice League books at the time were splintered and lacked focus. Got even worse post-Zero Hour. I left the series after Dan Jurgen's run.
>
> I'm satisified. Although, Meltzer's JLA reads way better as a graphic novel than a monthly comicbook series.


I think it's better and easier to state what was the best run of the series....that's easy! The original series, from it's inception in Brave and the Bold #28, late 1959, thru to the end of the Satellite era in 1984, JLA vol. 1 Annual 2. Everything since then has been a pale imitation. The Giffen/Demattis run started off pretty well...a return to being "the world's greatest super heroes", but quickly big guns were removed (suprisingly they took out Capt. Marvel, Dr.Fate, Capt.Atom, Dr.Light, Black Canary, Mr. Miracle) and we got Booster Gold, Fire and Ice and the stupid non-stop humor. Then there were the years of the late 80's and early 90's with 3 or 4 titles and lack of focus, The new book with Morrison....it was too slick and superficial. Boring stuff ( I loved his quirky Doom Patrol stories....his JLA never worked for me)...the boring post Morrison run of the title, and the truly horrendous work of Meltzer. He did more to ruin the title than almost anyone (I HATE Identity Crisis and how it retroactively turned the JLA into amoral hypocrites, and based on the general poor reviews I've read/heard of on the new title I'm happy I never picked it up!)JLDetroit.....it brought an end to "world's greatest heroes"...but at least Gerry Conway tried to make it work....I give him credit for having the balls to stick with it for what, 3 years.....whether it was his doing or DC's editorial dictatorial decision (a lot was going on with most of the old characters in their solo books and mini series at the time)...they tried to follow Avengers#16/Stan Lee's lead when he was turning the Avengers from a JLA clone into a FF clone. Steel, and Vixen were cool, Gypsy had some promise (if used properly), Vibe even could've been used if it wasn't for the stupid racial cliches.....but not at the expense of the de-powering they went thru. However, it pales in comparison to the moral decline the series went thru when Meltzer decided to bring the questionable ethics/morals retroactively into the JLA's history. What is heroic about the book any more. I'd rather read old back issues than by any of the new crap.


Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 7 on Windows Vista
batmanbeyond13




For starters, Meltzer did an excellent job on Identity Crisis. But then he does JLA and I say what happened there? His JLA run was not that great. I liked it but I think the artwork was helping it. I think Mc Duffie saved the book. I really am enjoying his run. With his experience on JLU (which is the best show ever made), I think that he will give us some great stuff to come. And not since Morrison, have I enjoyed and looked forward to the book now that Mc Duffie is on board.


Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 6 on Windows 98
Baal




I think Meltzer's run suffered from being given too little editorial interference. The use of the wrong Aquaman is one sign of that. Dwayne's problems come from too much editorial interfernce. His firsts toryline got swallowed by the Black Canary-Green Arrow Wedding monster and then there's Salvation derailing him. Maybe they can decide to start treating a cartoon superstar with his roots in comics as well as a medium level novelist...


Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 7 /bsalsa.com/; on Windows Vista

Alvaro's Comicboards powered by On Topic™ © 2003-2022 Powermad Software