Justice Society of America >> View Thread

Author
The Rev




I've found a place that really over ordered on these and has already marked these down except for the Zauriel issue which I guess either hasn't come out yet or just came out. I'm trying to decide if I want to pick them up or not. Any opinions that are good, bad, or indifferent? Just curious.

The Rev


Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 7 on Windows XP
David Morgan




I think they all sucked excepted the Sargon the Sorcerer book.


Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 6 on Windows XP
oldman




> I think they all sucked excepted the Sargon the Sorcerer book.

True the Sargon book is the best but the one about Ibis was good too ... just stay away of the Zauriel book waste of money and time


Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 6 on Windows XP
Ed Love




> > I think they all sucked excepted the Sargon the Sorcerer book.
>
> True the Sargon book is the best but the one about Ibis was good too ... just stay away of the Zauriel book waste of money and time

Hmm. Those two were the whole reason I stayed away from the specials. A mini-series about setting up the replacing of Dr. Fate and along the way we get one-shots replacing 2 more golden-age magical characters for no real reason. Why not use the opportunity and tell us a story with the original characters, maybe restoring them to glory? Or to relate a story about them and Fate from the past? But, instead we got just more of the same old same old. Bleh. Was tempted to get the Black Alice one since she is an actual original character.


Posted with Mozilla Firefox 2.0.0.2 on Windows XP
oldman




> > > I think they all sucked excepted the Sargon the Sorcerer book.
> >
> > True the Sargon book is the best but the one about Ibis was good too ... just stay away of the Zauriel book waste of money and time
>
> Hmm. Those two were the whole reason I stayed away from the specials. A mini-series about setting up the replacing of Dr. Fate and along the way we get one-shots replacing 2 more golden-age magical characters for no real reason. Why not use the opportunity and tell us a story with the original characters, maybe restoring them to glory? Or to relate a story about them and Fate from the past? But, instead we got just more of the same old same old. Bleh. Was tempted to get the Black Alice one since she is an actual original character.


Well since Sargon was dead since 1986 ( swamp thing #50 )

Anf Ibis in the seve soldiers series ( zatanna #1 )
It was a little too late for them ...


Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 6 on Windows XP
Racer Cool




Overall ..... not very good. Detective Chimp and Zauriel were the only entertaining one shots. Having second thoughts whether or not to get Dr. Fate ..... if I decide that I will get it ...... giving it 4 issues.


Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 6 on Windows 2000
Ed Love




> > > > I think they all sucked excepted the Sargon the Sorcerer book.
> > >
> > > True the Sargon book is the best but the one about Ibis was good too ... just stay away of the Zauriel book waste of money and time
> >
> > Hmm. Those two were the whole reason I stayed away from the specials. A mini-series about setting up the replacing of Dr. Fate and along the way we get one-shots replacing 2 more golden-age magical characters for no real reason. Why not use the opportunity and tell us a story with the original characters, maybe restoring them to glory? Or to relate a story about them and Fate from the past? But, instead we got just more of the same old same old. Bleh. Was tempted to get the Black Alice one since she is an actual original character.
>
>
> Well since Sargon was dead since 1986 ( swamp thing #50 )
He's come back since then, and killed off again I believe.
>
> Anf Ibis in the seve soldiers series ( zatanna #1 )
As was Doctor 13, he's back and he has no powers at all.


> It was a little too late for them ...

Mystical heroes, especially ones with exterior power devices, tend to come back from the dead more easily than others. And their deaths were a bit weak, as they were both cannon fodder deaths for the most part, more to give a story more punch but not of any service to the characters themselves.

Even so, it gets at what I was talking about, what they gave us were two more replacement/legacy heroes, 1)something we now have a ton of already and 2) the whole point of this mini is setting up a mystical legacy character of a golden-age mystical hero, and so we have 2 one-shots focusing on replacements for 2 other golden-age mystical heroes? And in honoring them, it shucks the whole visual tradition of both of those heroes (the Chandu-esque turban and tux outfit as opposed to the top hat and turban Mandrake influence) in favor of a more superhero styled look which was one thing that made Dr. Fate a bit unique in the realm of superhero magicians.

I'd have much rather they did something unique and tell us a times-past story with the original characters and keeping true to those characters without half-baked darkening retcons to make them edgy. You know, require the writers to do a little research and write them actually in-character.


Posted with Mozilla Firefox 2.0.0.2 on Windows XP
NamelessFaceless




I dug that story, that character.

More interesting to me than Fate.


Posted with Apple Safari on MacOS X

Alvaro's Comicboards powered by On Topic™ © 2003-2018 Powermad Software