Based upon comic con, looks like DC will be ending the current JSA world 2 thing, and moving towards bringing back old Jsa squad?

if that happens, will black Superman and PG find their way back to real earth then?

I hope not. There are enough pseudo-Supermans there already. Send 'em all to Earth-20.

What is earth 20?

Earth-20 is from Morrison's Multiversity series. It's a world which is less populated than most of the others, and has a Society of Justice which comprises Dr Fate, Atom (Al Pratt), Green Lantern, Immortal Man, and Lady Blackhawk. I always thought it would have made an ideal home for the Earth-2 refugees, and be a way to unite and merge the two post-52 Societies.

My idea for the roster if I wrote the Justice Society comic:

Hourman (Rick Tyler) (leader)
Flash (Jay Garrick)
Damage (Grant Emerson)
Tomcat (Tom Bronson)
Cyclone (Maxine Hunkel)
Amazing Man (Markus Clay)
Power Girl (Karen Starr)
Doctor Mid-Nite (Pieter Cross)
Citizen Steel (Nate Heywood)
Green Lantern (Alan Scott) (big maybe on him)

I am amazed we have not had Doctor Mid-Nite by now, he was alluded to early in the 'Worlds Collide' series but nothing happened, just another example of there being so much squandered potential in Earth-2....

I fully support your suggestion/plea of Maxine Hunkel (and Stargirl to complement her) and I would like to see Markus Clay ressurected as he was such a good character who's potential was barely tapped... But then I have a soft spot for Anna Fortune as well for the same reasons.

I feel some regret at not having talked about Earth-2:Society for quite some time, other books lured my time away. But it is a sympton of how far this series has declined in my interest over the last two to three years. It has been very clear to me from the moment Tom Taylor dissapeared from the credits that DC Comics have deliberately vandalised the series and steered it into irrelevance, for what reason I can only wonder, Earth-2 was one of the few great hits of the 2011 restart and on reflection, and considering the thinking behing Rebirth, it does seem as if their heart was never much into the whole New 52 once that initial two years of sales thrust and publicity began to ebb away...

It is a matter of regret this as Earth-2 gave us a fresh and bold rethink on the whole JSA myth, and a very successful one intially, but now it seems the entire thing is redundant and lifeless.
I wonder, just how faithful to the original series of the Geoff Johns JSA will this new debut be...?

Here's how I picture the JSA members if I was writing the title:
Flash I (Jay Garrick): active member (joined in All-Star Comics #3) (returns in JSA Rebirth)Green Lantern I (Alan Scott): reserve member (joined in All-Star Comics #3) (how he got resurrected and how he returned is TBD)Hawkman I (Carter Hall): former member (joined in All-Star Comics #3)Atom I (Al Pratt): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #3)Doctor Fate I (Kent Nelson): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #3)Spectre I (Jim Corrigan): former member (joined in All-Star Comics #3)Sandman I (Wesley Dodds): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #3)Hourman I (Red Tyler): retired (joined in All-Star Comics #3)Johnny Thunder I and Thunderbolt (John L. Thunder): former member, now merged into Johnny Thunderbolt (joined in All-Star Comics #6)Superman I (Clark Kent): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #7 as an honorary member)Batman I (Bruce Wayne): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #7 as an honorary member)Starman I (Ted Grant): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #8)Doctor Mid-Nite I (Charles McNider): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #8)Wonder Woman I (Diana Prince): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #11 as secretary)Mister Terrific I (Terry Sloane): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #24)Wildcat I (Ted Grant): retired (joined in All-Star Comics #24)Black Canary I (Dinah Drake Lance): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #41)Robin I (Dick Grayson): deceased (joined in Justice League of America #55)Red Tornado II: former member (joined in Justice League of America #65)Star-Spangled Kid I (Sylvester Pemberton): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #58)Power Girl (Karen Starr): active member (joined in All-Star Comics #58) (returns in JSA #4)Huntress II (Helena Wayne): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #72)Hawkgirl I (Sheira Hall): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #1)Wonder Woman (Hippolyta): former member (joined in Wonder Woman #133)Sandman IV (Sanderson "Sandy" Hawkins): former member (joined in JSA #2)Starman VII (Jack Knight): retired (joined in JSA #2)Hourman III (Matthew Tyler): retired (joined in JSA #2)Atom Smasher (Albert Rothstein): former member (joined in JSA #2)Black Canary II (Dinah Laurel Lance): former member (joined in JSA #2)Miss America (Joan Dale): retired (joined in Young All-Stars Annual #1)Hawkgirl III (Sheira Saunders): former member (joined in JSA #4)Stargirl (Courtney Whitmore): former member (joined in JSA #4)Doctor Fate IV (Hector Hall): deceased (joined in JSA #4)Mister Terrific II (Michael Holt): former member (joined in JSA #11)Doctor Mid-Nite II (Pieter Cross): active member (joined in JSA #11) (returns in JSA #6)Jakeem Thunder (Jakeem Williams): former member (joined in JSA Secret Files #2)Black Adam (Teth-Adam): former member (joined in JSA #29)Hourman II (Rick Tyler): active leader (joined in JSA #37) (returns in JSA Rebirth)Captain Marvel (Billy Batson): former member (joined in JSA #37)Liberty Belle II (Jesse Chambers): former member (joined prior to Justice Society of America #1)Obsidian (Todd Rice): former member (joined prior to Justice Society of America #1)Damage (Grant Emerson): active member (joined in Justice Society of America #1) (resurrected in JSA Rebirth and returns in JSA #1)Starman VIII (Thom Kallor): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #1)Cyclone (Maxine Hunkel): active member (joined in Justice Society of America #1) (returns in JSA #2)Tomcat (Tom Bronson): active member (joined in Justice Society of America #4) (returns in JSA #1)Citizen Steel (Nate Heywood): active member (joined in Justice Society of America #7) (returns in JSA #10)Superman-22 (Kal-El): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #10)Judomaster III (Sonia Sato): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #11)Amazing Man III (Markus Clay): active member (joined in Justice Society of America #12) (returns in JSA #2)Lightning (Jennifer Pierce): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #12)Lance (David Reid): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #12)Mister America III (Jeffrey Graves): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #13)All-American Kid (Jeremy Karne): traitor (joined in Justice Society of America #29)King Chimera: former member (joined in Justice Society of America #29)Doctor Fate V (Kent V. Nelson): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #30)Roxy: former member (joined in JSA All-Stars #2)Anna Fortune: former member (joined in JSA All-Stars #6)Manhunter IV (Kate Spencer): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #49)Red Beetle (Sara Butters): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #49)Ri: former member (joined in Justice Society of America #49)Darknight: former member (joined in Justice Society of America #49)Liberty Belle I (Libby Lawrence): retired (joined in Justice Society of America #49)
I'm currently debating on adding Green Lantern I, Stargirl, Sandman IV, and Liberty Belle II to the group as well as brand new members. For one thing, I am a big fan of Geoff Johns' JSA, as well as the 2007-2011 JSA.

Just seems that pretty much everything done around new 52 ran out of steam, and so the Rebirth would be best to re show us back the original JSA team..

Here's an update: my JSA team was kinda lackluster, so I decide to add two important members to the team. The first being Alan Scott, the first Green Lantern himself. I know he died in Justice Society of America #54, but he can always return. After all, his body is composed of green flame. Second, in keeping with Geoff Johns' JSA tradition, I decided to add Stargirl since she is one of Geoff's signature characters (and based on his late sister). With Stargirl MIA since Rebirth, I say the perfect title for Courtney to be on is Justice Society of America. So my roster is now Hourman (Rick) as leader, Flash (Jay), Damage, Tomcat, Cyclone, Amazing Man (Marcus), Power Girl, Doctor Mid-Nite (Pieter), Citizen Steel, Green Lantern (Alan), and Stargirl. So, let's review the roster, shall we:Flash I (Jay Garrick): active member (joined in All-Star Comics #3) (returns in JSA Rebirth)Green Lantern I (Alan Scott): active member (joined in All-Star Comics #3) (returns in JSA #15)Hawkman I (Carter Hall): former member (joined in All-Star Comics #3)Atom I (Al Pratt): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #3)Doctor Fate I (Kent Nelson): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #3)Spectre I (Jim Corrigan): former member (joined in All-Star Comics #3)Sandman I (Wesley Dodds): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #3)Hourman I (Red Tyler): retired (joined in All-Star Comics #3)Johnny Thunder I and Thunderbolt (John L. Thunder): former member, now merged into Johnny Thunderbolt (joined in All-Star Comics #6)Superman I (Clark Kent): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #7 as an honorary member)Batman I (Bruce Wayne): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #7 as an honorary member)Starman I (Ted Grant): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #8)Doctor Mid-Nite I (Charles McNider): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #8)Wonder Woman I (Diana Prince): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #11 as secretary)Mister Terrific I (Terry Sloane): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #24)Wildcat I (Ted Grant): retired (joined in All-Star Comics #24)Black Canary I (Dinah Drake Lance): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #41)Robin I (Dick Grayson): deceased (joined in Justice League of America #55)Red Tornado II: former member (joined in Justice League of America #65)Star-Spangled Kid I (Sylvester Pemberton): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #58)Power Girl (Karen Starr): active member (joined in All-Star Comics #58) (returns in JSA #4)Huntress II (Helena Wayne): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #72)Hawkgirl I (Sheira Hall): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #1)Wonder Woman (Hippolyta): former member (joined in Wonder Woman #133)Sandman IV (Sanderson "Sandy" Hawkins): former member (joined in JSA #2)Starman VII (Jack Knight): retired (joined in JSA #2)Hourman III (Matthew Tyler): retired (joined in JSA #2)Atom Smasher (Albert Rothstein): former member (joined in JSA #2)Black Canary II (Dinah Laurel Lance): former member (joined in JSA #2)Miss America (Joan Dale): retired (joined in Young All-Stars Annual #1)Hawkgirl III (Sheira Saunders): former member (joined in JSA #4)Stargirl (Courtney Whitmore): active member (joined in JSA #4) (returns in JSA #18)Doctor Fate IV (Hector Hall): deceased (joined in JSA #4)Mister Terrific II (Michael Holt): former member (joined in JSA #11)Doctor Mid-Nite II (Pieter Cross): active member (joined in JSA #11) (returns in JSA #6)Jakeem Thunder (Jakeem Williams): former member (joined in JSA Secret Files #2)Black Adam (Teth-Adam): former member (joined in JSA #29)Hourman II (Rick Tyler): active leader (joined in JSA #37) (returns in JSA Rebirth)Captain Marvel (Billy Batson): former member (joined in JSA #37)Liberty Belle II (Jesse Chambers): former member (joined prior to Justice Society of America #1)Obsidian (Todd Rice): former member (joined prior to Justice Society of America #1)Damage (Grant Emerson): active member (joined in Justice Society of America #1) (resurrected in JSA Rebirth and returns in JSA #1)Starman VIII (Thom Kallor): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #1)Cyclone (Maxine Hunkel): active member (joined in Justice Society of America #1) (returns in JSA #2)Tomcat (Tom Bronson): active member (joined in Justice Society of America #4) (returns in JSA #1)Citizen Steel (Nate Heywood): active member (joined in Justice Society of America #7) (returns in JSA #10)Superman-22 (Kal-El): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #10)Judomaster III (Sonia Sato): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #11)Amazing Man III (Markus Clay): active member (joined in Justice Society of America #12) (returns in JSA #2)Lightning (Jennifer Pierce): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #12)Lance (David Reid): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #12)Mister America III (Jeffrey Graves): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #13)All-American Kid (Jeremy Karne): traitor (joined in Justice Society of America #29)King Chimera: former member (joined in Justice Society of America #29)Doctor Fate V (Kent V. Nelson): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #30)Roxy: former member (joined in JSA All-Stars #2)Anna Fortune: former member (joined in JSA All-Stars #6)Manhunter IV (Kate Spencer): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #49)Red Beetle (Sara Butters): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #49)Ri: former member (joined in Justice Society of America #49)Darknight: former member (joined in Justice Society of America #49)Liberty Belle I (Libby Lawrence): retired (joined in Justice Society of America #49)
I'm currently debating on adding Sandman IV and Liberty Belle II to the group as well as brand new members. I hope Geoff Johns is reading this.

Quote:
Here's an update: my JSA team was kinda lackluster, so I decide to add two important members to the team. The first being Alan Scott, the first Green Lantern himself. I know he died in Justice Society of America #54, but he can always return. After all, his body is composed of green flame.

I had forgotten Alan Scott's fate, ironically similar to what happened to his daughter Jade in Infinite Crisis, and like her I would fully expect him to be able to ressurect in due course...
Not that I think the new JSA hinted at in Rebirth will be a continuation of that continuity, but as I have said before the way I see it the JSA will be returned from the limbo that Johnny Thunder sent them to and we will probobly learn that despite their erasure from the worlds memory their children and wider family carried on and so it is quite possible that the likes of Stargirl, Maxine Hunkel, Black Canary, and Mr Terrific are to be revealed as linked to this heritage. I think that would be a neat reveal.

Then of course the conundrum will be whether the likes of The Huntress, Power Girl, Hector Hall, Liberty Belle, Johnny Quick, Jade, Atom Smasher, and Jack Knight can still exist in this revised history. Jack Knight in particular is a thorny issue as his story ends with James Robinson, but in practical terms that series of Starman is a very important and influential volume for DC - would it not be sensible to restore it to canon?

I'm still keeping the group as Hourman (Rick), Flash (Jay), Damage, Tomcat, Cyclone, Amazing Man (Markus), Power Girl, Doctor Mid-Nite (Pieter), Citizen Steel, Green Lantern (Alan), and Stargirl if I am writing the comic. Here's how the roster will be:
JSA Rebirth: Hourman and Flash
JSA 1: Hourman, Flash, Damage, and Tomcat
JSA 2-3: Hourman, Flash, Damage, Tomcat, Cyclone, and Amazing Man
JSA 4-5: Hourman, Flash, Damage, Tomcat, Cyclone, Amazing Man, and Power Girl
JSA 6-9: Hourman, Flash, Damage, Tomcat, Cyclone, Amazing Man, Power Girl, and Doctor Mid-Nite
JSA 10-14: Hourman, Flash, Damage, Tomcat, Cyclone, Amazing Man, Power Girl, Doctor Mid-Nite, and Citizen Steel
JSA 15-17: Hourman, Flash, Damage, Tomcat, Cyclone, Amazing Man, Power Girl, Doctor Mid-Nite, Citizen Steel, and Green Lantern
JSA 18-Onwards: Hourman, Flash, Damage, Tomcat, Cyclone, Amazing Man, Power Girl, Doctor Mid-Nite, Citizen Steel, Green Lantern, and Stargirl
Now, if only I can put Sandman IV (Sanderson), Liberty Belle II (Jesse), and some newcomers in as well.

I wonder why you have Damage and Tomcat as regulars, neither were terribly memorable, though Damage in particular had a rough time in the book, as with Atom Smasher I was never convinced with the treatment Geoff Johns handed to Grant and felt he was rather wasted for a moments sensationalism.
Logically if DC are set on returning the JSA it will (or should) be a given that Jay Garrick will be automatically in the group, Hourman and Wildcat are almost certain, since Johnny Thunder is an old man will his unnamed granddaughter take on his Thunderbolt perhaps? Or perhaps she has a grandson named Jakeem...?
I will go on record and predict Stargirl will be in there - she really has not any other place to go in the DCU and frankly the JSA is her home in the same way the Titans is Vic Stone's home. But will the Hawks make the cut I wonder...? Surely yes, I would see Carter and Shiera/Kendra as likely as quite apart from the Legends of Tomorrow television exposure the revived Katar Hol has not been able to find any real traction in the DC stable since his revival in 2011. Carter and Shiera/Kendra seem to have supplanted him and Shayera in the audiences affections and recognition factor.

Will they have a Superman on the group though?

I kind of hope not.  As much as I love the Earth-2 Superman, the younger version simply doesn't have those JSA ties and would feel shoehorned in to me.

I'm not a big fan of Superman (or Batman) as JSA members. If I was writing the comic, I would bring it to how Geoff Johns would write it and my roster will be:
Hourman (Rick Tyler) (leader)
Flash (Jay Garrick)
Damage (Grant Emerson)
Tomcat (Tom Bronson)
Cyclone (Maxine Hunkel)
Amazing Man (Markus Clay)
Power Girl (Karen Starr)
Doctor Mid-Nite (Pieter Cross)
Citizen Steel (Nate Heywood)
Green Lantern (Alan Scott)
Stargirl (Courtney Whitmore)
and maybe Sandman (Sanderson Hawkins) and Liberty Belle (Jesse Chambers)
And as for the JSA roster in general, here's how it stands:Flash I (Jay Garrick): active member (joined in All-Star Comics #3) (returns in JSA Rebirth)
Green Lantern I (Alan Scott): active member (joined in All-Star Comics #3) (returns in JSA #15)
Hawkman I (Carter Hall): former member (joined in All-Star Comics #3)
Atom I (Al Pratt): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #3)
Doctor Fate I (Kent Nelson): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #3)
Spectre I (Jim Corrigan): former member (joined in All-Star Comics #3)
Sandman I (Wesley Dodds): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #3)
Hourman I (Red Tyler): retired (joined in All-Star Comics #3)
Johnny Thunder I and Thunderbolt (John L. Thunder): former member, now merged into Johnny Thunderbolt (joined in All-Star Comics #6)
Superman I (Clark Kent): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #7 as an honorary member)
Batman I (Bruce Wayne): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #7 as an honorary member)
Starman I (Ted Grant): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #8)
Doctor Mid-Nite I (Charles McNider): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #8)
Wonder Woman I (Diana Prince): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #11 as secretary)
Mister Terrific I (Terry Sloane): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #24)
Wildcat I (Ted Grant): retired (joined in All-Star Comics #24)
Black Canary I (Dinah Drake Lance): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #41)
Robin I (Dick Grayson): deceased (joined in Justice League of America #55)
Red Tornado II: former member (joined in Justice League of America #65)
Star-Spangled Kid I (Sylvester Pemberton): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #58)
Power Girl (Karen Starr): active member (joined in All-Star Comics #58) (returns in JSA #4)
Huntress II (Helena Wayne): deceased (joined in All-Star Comics #72)
Miss America (Joan Dale): retired (joined in Young All-Stars Annual #1)
Hawkgirl I (Sheira Hall): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #1)
Wonder Woman (Hippolyta): former member (joined in Wonder Woman #133)
Sandman IV (Sanderson "Sandy" Hawkins): reserve member (joined in JSA #2)
Starman VII (Jack Knight): retired (joined in JSA #2)
Hourman III (Matthew Tyler): retired (joined in JSA #2)
Atom Smasher (Albert Rothstein): former member (joined in JSA #2)
Black Canary II (Dinah Laurel Lance): former member (joined in JSA #2)
Hawkgirl III (Sheira Saunders): former member (joined in JSA #4)
Stargirl (Courtney Whitmore): active member (joined in JSA #4) (returns in JSA #18)
Doctor Fate IV (Hector Hall): deceased (joined in JSA #4)
Mister Terrific II (Michael Holt): former member (joined in JSA #11)
Doctor Mid-Nite II (Pieter Cross): active member (joined in JSA #11) (returns in JSA #6)
Jakeem Thunder (Jakeem Williams): former member (joined in JSA Secret Files #2)
Black Adam (Teth-Adam): former member (joined in JSA #29)
Hourman II (Rick Tyler): active leader (joined in JSA #37) (returns in JSA Rebirth)
Captain Marvel (Billy Batson): former member (joined in JSA #37)
Liberty Belle II (Jesse Chambers): reserve member (joined prior to Justice Society of America #1)
Obsidian (Todd Rice): former member (joined prior to Justice Society of America #1)
Damage (Grant Emerson): active member (joined in Justice Society of America #1) (resurrected in JSA Rebirth and returns in JSA #1)
Starman VIII (Thom Kallor): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #1)
Cyclone (Maxine Hunkel): active member (joined in Justice Society of America #1) (returns in JSA #2)
Tomcat (Tom Bronson): active member (joined in Justice Society of America #4) (returns in JSA #1)
Citizen Steel (Nate Heywood): active member (joined in Justice Society of America #7) (returns in JSA #10)
Superman-22 (Kal-El): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #10)
Judomaster III (Sonia Sato): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #11)
Amazing Man III (Markus Clay): active member (joined in Justice Society of America #12) (returns in JSA #2)
Lightning (Jennifer Pierce): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #12)
Lance (David Reid): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #12)
Mister America III (Jeffrey Graves): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #13)
All-American Kid (Jeremy Karne): traitor (joined in Justice Society of America #29)
King Chimera: former member (joined in Justice Society of America #29)
Doctor Fate V (Kent V. Nelson): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #30)
Roxy: former member (joined in JSA All-Stars #2)
Anna Fortune: former member (joined in JSA All-Stars #6)
Manhunter IV (Kate Spencer): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #49)
Red Beetle (Sara Butters): former member (joined in Justice Society of America #49)
Ri: former member (joined in Justice Society of America #49)
Darknight: former member (joined in Justice Society of America #49)
Liberty Belle I (Libby Lawrence): retired (joined in Justice Society of America #49)
Hope that answers my views for everyone.