X-Universe >> View Thread

Author
stupid baby




whats is the 1st appearance of Guido Carosella ( strong guy ) ?

when I was younger, in the 90s, i alaways read that it was New Mutants annual 2,( or maybe it was annual 1 ) so i ways thought thats what it was. I had just read about a week ago that his 1st was in New Mutants # 29. Which I just got, read and enjoyed, in #29, the kids act like this is the first time they had seen him...

so I was just wondering if anyone could clarify this.
also why does such a discrepency exist?

did one come out first , but the other takes place first or something like that?

cuz that was the case with Exodus' frist appearance in the early 90s.


Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 5.0 on Windows Vista
The Black Guardian 

Moderator

Location: Paragon City, RI
Member Since: Sat May 17, 2008
Posts: 26,341



    Quote:
    whats is the 1st appearance of Guido Carosella ( strong guy ) ?

    when I was younger, in the 90s, i alaways read that it was New Mutants annual 2,( or maybe it was annual 1 ) so i ways thought thats what it was. I had just read about a week ago that his 1st was in New Mutants # 29. Which I just got, read and enjoyed, in #29, the kids act like this is the first time they had seen him...

    so I was just wondering if anyone could clarify this.
    also why does such a discrepency exist?

    did one come out first , but the other takes place first or something like that?

    cuz that was the case with Exodus' frist appearance in the early 90s.

You must mean New Mutant Annual #1, since that was the Lila Cheney issue. However, Guido makes no appearance there. We see several of Lila's band and staff, but no Guido anywhere. New Mutants #29 was always his first appearance. Guido doesn't even appear in any New Mutants Annual or Special. In fact, I think #29 is his only appearance in any New Mutants issue at all.

The discrepancy is in your head, I'm afraid. You likely mistakenly thought he appeared along with Lila Cheney in her first appearance, but that isn't the case. He was a later addition to her story.




City of Heroes is BACK!
Posted with Mozilla Firefox 15.0.1 on Windows 7
stupid baby




yeah, perhaps the discrepency is in my mind after all,
regardless, Ive got both annuals and # 29.
So, as an xfactor fan, im happy,
thanks for writing back so soon.


Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 5.0 on Windows Vista

Alvaro's Comicboards powered by On Topic™ © 2003-2018 Powermad Software