Black Panther >> View Post
Post By
pantherlord

In Reply To
pendex

Subj: Re: dwayne mcduffie writing style is obsolete, fanboy oriented and boring
Posted: Wed Jun 06, 2007 at 03:51:35 am EDT
Reply Subj: Re: dwayne mcduffie writing style is obsolete, fanboy oriented and boring
Posted: Tue Jun 05, 2007 at 11:42:51 pm EDT

Previous Post

in my opinion, someone who son't like LOEG or WATChmen IS JUST A retarded person.

my opinion about mcduffie is simply that his writing is obsolete, ala claremont, with stupid dialogues in the middle of the fight explaining your enemy what powers are you going to use against him, or what are you doing.
pathetic

and don't be ridiculous, Moore is on the major leagues, mc daffie , who is him?? please!!!

i am not a hater per se

> in my opinion, someone who son't like LOEG or WATChmen IS JUST A retarded person.
>
> my opinion about mcduffie is simply that his writing is obsolete, ala claremont, with stupid dialogues in the middle of the fight explaining your enemy what powers are you going to use against him, or what are you doing.
> pathetic
>
> and don't be ridiculous, Moore is on the major leagues, mc daffie , who is him?? please!!!
>
> i am not a hater per se

Dwayne McDuffie is a pretty good writer. He is a much better writer than Hudlin ever will be. However Dwayne McDuffie's writing is very much like fan fiction in that while good it does not elevate the character of Black Panther to a new level. Dwayne McDuffie is trying his best, but his best is just homage to Priest's writing and not the real deal.

There are only two writers I know of that have been shown to be able to write Black Panther. These two are Don McGregor and Christopher Priest. Hudlin is a hack that could not write to save his life and McDuffie is an imitator, albeit a good one.