Comic Battle >> View Post
·
Post By
dvlish

In Reply To
J

Subj: Re: ok but....
Posted: Mon Jan 15, 2007 at 11:48:46 am CST
Reply Subj: Re: ok but....
Posted: Mon Jan 15, 2007 at 11:31:38 am CST

Previous Post

The Goddess
Dark Phoenix
Umar
The Queen Of Fables
Selene
The Sphynx
Karnilla
Hela

Then there are others like:

Gamora
Mantis
Moondragon
Kismet
Sersi
Thena
Meggan

And as others have pointed out: Elektra, Mystique, Nebula, Morgan Le Fay, etc.

And the idea that you use Thanos as the basis for menacing is nuts. How many characters are as powerful as Thanos? Nearly none (cosmic entities excluded, of course).

And the point is that someone posted that a woman cant be menacing - they didnt say a woman cant be as powerful as Thanos (which isnt true: Goddess, Dark Phoenix, etc).


> If you put Nebula beside Thanos who would be more menacing? or even if you put her beside Ronan or the Super Skrull or any other male cosmic villain.
>
> same goes with mystique, put her beside Sabertooth and her menacing-ness (i made a word! lol) would greatly diminish.
>
> while it is true that there are strong portrayals of women in comic books who can also depict themselves in a very capable manner, sadly there is still a definite gap between the perceptions and interpretations when stacking strong female characters against strong male characters.

my main point was that if you put a strong, capable female like Mystique beside a strong and equally capable male peer, more often than not people would be more afraid of the male version. You do have good points about strong female characters (Dark Phoenix being the best example), but you have to face the truth, there is a difference in perception between a female charcter and a male character when stacked together. For every "menacing" female character, there are probably 2 or 3 male ones that would be equal or more. For every Dark Phoenix there is a Thanos and a Darkseid, for every Elektra there is a Bullseye or Deathstroke.

if you put Mystique in a room of MU civilians, I'm sure people would be terrified, but if you put Mystique AND Sabertooth in a room together, people would be more terrified of Sabertooth. It doesn't even have to be Sabertooth.. you can replace him with Post, Harvest, Stryfe.. etc. and they would have a more menacing prescence to people.


Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 6 on Windows XP
Alvaro's Comicboards powered by On Topic™ © 2003-2022 Powermad Software
All the content of these boards Copyright © 1996-2022 by Comicboards/TVShowboards. Software Copyright © 2003-2022 Powermad Software