Comic Battle >> View Post
Post By
rukkdeez

In Reply To
Would Be Watcher

Subj: Re: canon or not...
Posted: Sat Jan 20, 2007 at 08:21:04 pm EST
Reply Subj: canon or not...
Posted: Sat Jan 20, 2007 at 06:03:58 pm EST

Previous Post

> > > > > Could the current Hulk be able to defeat the Mongul of the PC era of the DCU, one who actually managed to defeat PC Supes after epic battle, yay or nay?
> > > >
> > > > Lord Majestros:
> > > > Pre-Crisis Supes said in no uncertain terms that Mongul took everything he had and Mongul STILL got the better of him.
> > >
> > > Well... Modern Supes was able to KO the Hulk, who nearly took everything Supes had...
> > > So if Modern Supes is able to KO Hulk, and if PC Supes could not KO Mongul, than ?
> >
> > That was in a fan voted match. Not the best example to use, you will agree.
>
> Thats just it! Certain people here DON'T agree! This is why despite the fact that EVERYONE knows that was a fan voted fight (especially the people who keep referring and using this fight as a basis for their arguments)people STILL act as though this battle was canon. What I'd like to know is....WHY?

a well written story with the same match up would and should have the same result. I'm sorry but no amount of talking is going to make me beleive that hulk can win unless a plot device or a jobbing appears.

> > > > > > Could the current Hulk be able to defeat the Mongul of the PC era of the DCU, one who actually managed to defeat PC Supes after epic battle, yay or nay?
> > > > >
> > > > > Lord Majestros:
> > > > > Pre-Crisis Supes said in no uncertain terms that Mongul took everything he had and Mongul STILL got the better of him.
> > > >
> > > > Well... Modern Supes was able to KO the Hulk, who nearly took everything Supes had...
> > > > So if Modern Supes is able to KO Hulk, and if PC Supes could not KO Mongul, than ?
> > >
> > > That was in a fan voted match. Not the best example to use, you will agree.
> >
> > Thats just it! Certain people here DON'T agree! This is why despite the fact that EVERYONE knows that was a fan voted fight (especially the people who keep referring and using this fight as a basis for their arguments)people STILL act as though this battle was canon. What I'd like to know is....WHY?
>
> a well written story with the same match up would and should have the same result. I'm sorry but no amount of talking is going to make me beleive that hulk can win unless a plot device or a jobbing appears.

So the story would be "well written" ONLY if Supes is victorious. And if the Hulk happened to win, it just HAS to be a job or plot device eh? And this is why? Because YOU wouldn't believe it otherwise. Anything other than a Superman victory would constitute a poorly written story. According to YOU. I see.