Comic Battle >> View Post
Post By
Marv

Member Since: Sat Jan 24, 2015
Posts: 5,862
In Reply To
abhijit

Subj: Re: he beat Zonuz, Darkseid father with Source manipulation powers, in the NU52
Posted: Wed Feb 08, 2017 at 07:23:05 am EST (Viewed 179 times)
Reply Subj: Re: he beat Zonuz, Darkseid father with Source manipulation powers, in the NU52
Posted: Wed Feb 08, 2017 at 01:53:01 am EST (Viewed 160 times)

Previous Post


    Quote:
    The whole powerset of cap marvel is being powered up by 6 different gods, so yes, context implies that Cap Marvel has the potential to fight and win darkseid level threats. And the Zonuz fight happens AFTER darkseid died, so the darkseid from the battle before is not facing the same cap marvel, and Zonuz specifically repeats that he IS Yuga Khan, the father of Darkseid, planning to use the SHAZAM power to replace his fallen son once again. so it is a comparable level of villain to darkseid, considering his previous feats against his own son.

That's quite a leap in logic I'd say but looking back at this board, I'm not exactly surprised.

And no, it doesn't means Cap can beat Darkseid on his own.



    Quote:
    You seem to consider comic characters too one dimensionally, when there is a definite range of potential use of a character that tends to go beyond "the norm" or even the logic of powersets. Shazam is definitely on the same range of a Superman if need be.


Yes, you really convinced me with that logic.


Maybe not, but it means that he beat someone who is on the same range though. and since indirect comparisons is a big part of what you are talking about, i think it's pretty logical to do so. 

Of course, direct comparisons set more of a "norm", so i get that you want things to be spelled out and directly shown. There are plenty of stories where Superman and Cap Marvel are considered peers and equals on a norm, but those apparently are not good enough because in specific occasions the result was more to your liking, right? nevermind there are occasions when Cap Marvel defeated Superman as well like in All Star Squadron 9, JLA 36 and JLA/JSA Virtue and Vice...those don't count because they don't fit your point, right?

when i say someone is a peer or has a similar range, i mean exactly that, so no result is foregone beforehand, it all depends on the context. But the potential use of the character concept permits a peer to win in a specific enough condition, even just based on mindset and feelings at the time of the battle. Some versions of Shazam could very well be enough to beat Darkseid on their own, just like some wouldn't. Some versions of Darkseid punked Superman like he was nothing after all, but i don't think it's impossible for his character concept to ramp up to a point where he could beat him...