|Comic Battle >> View Post|
Subj: Re: I will agree the scan is somewhat open to interpretation
Posted: Thu Feb 01, 2018 at 02:35:10 pm EST (Viewed 123 times)
Reply Subj: Re: I will agree the scan is somewhat open to interpretation
Posted: Thu Feb 01, 2018 at 01:05:30 pm EST (Viewed 143 times)
On your first point, I agree wholeheartedly. Its speculative whether Desaad was posing as DS in the fight involved. Reasonable speculation, sure, but no slam dunk by any stretch.
On the second, I'll certainly say if I were a junior editor looking for a cool product to put out, that fight is a pretty cool one.
We act like every employee of DC comics builds an encyclopedic knowledge of their continuity, and they don't.
I'm amazed at how poorly many organizations operate, and how poorly they communicate, and how poorly understood their products are by employees that should know.
I'm sure someone picked that fight because they liked it. Whether they're even aware of the supposed retcon or not is speculatory, and I'd doubt they ever saw or remembered that page. I also doubt there's any major discussions about the continuity implications of that conversation between DS and Desaad.
As such, I'd certainly bet that most any junior editor in DC would look at the comic and say 'yeah, its Darkseid'. If you then show them the supposed retcon, they'd either say 'oh, it was Desaad' or 'maybe, probably still Darkseid'.
Sure, the EIC may have an idea, and a few writers of the most relevant books, or if one editor had been on the Superman books for the entire duration you might get someone with a strong opinion, but for the most part, this is a 'small potatoes' issue. It matters to a few fans, sure, but you ascribe far too much in the way of adherence to what is or is not in continuity than they are likely to do....