Comic Battle - Re: Another Battle Scan: Superman vs. Darkseid: Action Comic

Post By

motifian

Member Since: Sat May 17, 2008
Posts: 3,077

In Reply To

zvelf

Member Since: Sat May 17, 2008

Subj: Re: Another Battle Scan: Superman vs. Darkseid: Action Comics #586
Posted: Mon Feb 12, 2018 at 02:46:11 am EST (Viewed 119 times)

Reply Subj: Re: Another Battle Scan: Superman vs. Darkseid: Action Comics #586
Posted: Sun Feb 11, 2018 at 10:33:10 am EST (Viewed 167 times)

Quote:

In the same arc? The Superman writers were well informed from the get go about the whole arc.

Writers still vary in their depictions. You yourself stated in this very thread that Joe Casey presented a much more powerful Superman than everyone else in this arc.

I'm not sure if you're aware but superman writers were all in sync one year before any arc was released. So it was Superman who was more powerful and more durable than Imperiex then who tanked Omega beams?

Quote:

Imperiex didn't tank omega beams. Imperiex lost when he got hit by a combination of omega beams and Superman while possessed by an "Eternity"-level Kismet. And you already contradicted yourself on your Superman writers statement.

So Superman >>Imperiex because he tanked the omega beams?

Quote:

Nothing about #643 indicates that it was Desaad in #586. By your logic, Desaad is always Darkseid.

Only where he is shown as such.

And he wasn't shown as such in Action Comics #586 so you're wrong.

He was shown as such in New Gods so no I'm not wrong.

Quote:

There was no specifying a retcon of Action Comics #586 there.

In New gods it is.

Quote:

Only the shield had the Odin force as stated by Thor. It was only his belt of strength.

Thor never states this and you can't prove it.

Yes, he does. Already proved it.

Quote:

No, you have merely asserted this to be the case. If you've proven it, point out the post in which you did beyond mere assertion. You can't.

I've already posted the scan where Thor states such.

Quote:

I'll just let the scans in this very thread speak for themselves, and they show Superman beating Darkseid in three different instances very clearly. Superman doesn't just stun Darkseid, your ridiculous definition of a win, but beats Darkseid so badly Darkseid has to admit defeat.

Yeah, right. Only after Darkseid injures himself. Which you're only ignoring till now.

I haven't ignored it at all. I've already addressed this supposed "injury" throughout this thread and you made up that Darkseid somehow gets "short circuited" by his own omegas.

Both have already been proven.

Quote:

No, you have merely asserted this to be the case. If you've proven it, point out the post in which you did beyond mere assertion. You can't.

No, both have been proven repeatedly. You're dismissed.