Community >> View Post
·
Post By
???

Member Since: Sat May 17, 2008
In Reply To
The Avenger

Location: New Jersey
Member Since: Thu Dec 02, 2021
Subj: There is a problem with the question.
Posted: Tue Apr 19, 2022 at 06:36:41 am EDT (Viewed 176 times)
Reply Subj: Is classical music dead?
Posted: Mon Apr 11, 2022 at 11:49:05 am EDT (Viewed 232 times)

Previous Post

The quick answer is, "No" - but it requires thinking through what classical music is.

Is it the music of Old Europe? I ask this because the blues, jazz, country, and rock all originated in the United States. If you eliminate not only those genres but all of their influence, what you're left with (in the West) is the music of Old Europe. Is that what classical music is? If so, then classical music only exists as a very large but closed catalogue, handed down through the centuries, beginning about 500 CE and ending, let's arbitrarily say, with the death of Johannes Brahms in 1897.

But some modern composers think classical music doesn't have to be kept in that cage. They bring in other influences, for example indie rock, and electronica, and traditional music from non-European cultures. For these visionaries, classical music continually evolves, and can only be enriched by contact with new ways of making beauty with sound. Some of these composers are discussed here:
https://theculturetrip.com/north-america/usa/articles/top-10-young-composers-who-are-redefining-classical-music/

I would include some 20th century composers as falling into the same category as the young composers discussed in the above article. The most famous and obvious is Igor Stravinsky.

And what of movie soundtracks? When I asked my daughter if classical music was dead, she said, "No, because we still hear it in movies." I think a lot of us, myself included, would agree with that conclusion. I would merely add that movie soundtracks represent another evolution of classical, indeed another fusion of classical with something else: it's a fusion with cinematography! I think it's crucial, and exciting, to remember that. Movie soundtracks contribute to the telling of a visual story! Is this new? Actually, no. Ballet has a soundtrack, and opera does as well. Yet cinematography differs from ballet, and differs from opera as well. It's the third evolution of musical storytelling! (I consider Broadway musicals to be an offshoot of opera, differing only in superficial ways, driven more by popular taste than by any serious aesthetic philosophy. Thus we have ballet, opera/Broadway, and cinematography.)

So is classical music dead? No, it's forever evolving.


Classical music does not just mean symphonies and orchestras.

It was a term coined specifically to refer to that type of music, created before the rise of the music industry i.e, before recording.

It was done by... snobs, who were less than trilled about different types of music taking becoming popular with people. Especially sine music like Blues and Jazz have roots in American folk music. So, the common people were deciding the popularity of music, instead of former taste makers.

So, it has more to do with when, not what.

Think of it like this, there is no new classic rock. The term specifically refers to music from the 50s-70s. Not even necessarily the 50s, or all of the 70s.

The 80s and 90s are further from now than that classic rock era was when the term was coined, but people are not rushing to call music form those decades classic rock.

There are two interesting elements to this...

1) It proved that those snobs were ultimately wrong. At the time classic music was being produced they looked down on folk music as being lesser, and and it being far more influential with it often being tied to cultural studies.

Also, because Blues not only came from folk music, but was one of those early music types they wanted to brand as lesser, and became the most influential music ever.

It spawned R & B, and Rock music. Adding more blues in varying forms gave us the Rolling Stones, and psychedelic, both of which were influences on early punk bands like MC5 and the Stooges, as well as early Metal like Steppen Wolf and Black Sabbath,

Blues was also the roots of funk, which is what led to rap.

Also country music came form folk music, which means that that the very music they thought as lesser became the most versatile and dominant form of music ever, through its decedents.


2) that similar versions of that type of gatekeeping would keep happening over time, in various degrees.

Some of it was generational, with Greatest generation jazz nuts hating rock, those same baby boomers who defended rock hating their kids and rap, or pre-war jazz fans having contempt for the likes of Miles Davis and Coltrane and visa versa (look up the jazz term 'moldy fig')


Other far more sinister As Bob Dylan once pointed out, in the early 60s as rock n roll became established through white musicians, many record store owners did weird stuff. Namely, having music that was very similar being designated as Rock n' Roll if the artist was white and R & B if they were black.


The very idea of classical music is the grandfather of every music snob, parent telling their kid to turn down the racket, race based music marketing and blocking, and high school clique defined by the type of music they listened to


So, is classical music dead?

It is more like the old rich curmudgeon on the hill that never leaves their home, and dislikes their kids and grand kids for mixing with the new money and less well-off.


Posted with Mozilla Firefox 97.0 on Windows 10
Alvaro's Comicboards powered by On Topic™ © 2003-2022 Powermad Software
All the content of these boards Copyright © 1996-2022 by Comicboards/TVShowboards. Software Copyright © 2003-2022 Powermad Software