Quote:
Then every detective should quit. Because all they have to go on is evidence, not proof. Then they extrapolate forward from the evidence. But by your reasoning, al the detective does is 'guesswork'.
But you are not doing what detectives do. You are not extrapolating forward from the evidence, because there isn’t any. You only make baseless claims that cannot be proven, and unjustly claim them as authoritative. You have nothing to base your claims on, and that is what makes it guesswork.
Quote:
I think you need to look into it a little deeper.
That is not possible until time travel becomes a reality.
Quote:
Lol! No. I'm criticising the writers' handling of one topic based on their poor handling of other topics. If they get one thing wrong, fair enough. But when they get many things wrong, it's safe to assume there's probably other instances of poor writing.
You have just committed an Ad hominem fallacy. Statements are not proven wrong because of the person who makes them. The writers’ verified scientific mistakes do not make anything else they write automatically wrong.
