I mean, let's look at it:
An anonymous poster (and yes, anonymous is not giving your e-mail, and a password to edit your post if need be) comes here and makes an initially vague post, basically saying "Hey guys, stuff is going to happen and I didn't like what I heard." but does mention that the comics and movies should more resemble each other. No source is cited.
He comes back saying something like "Okay fanboy, here's your spoilers" and says Peter is back in high school. Considering that high school isn't in the movies, this makes no sense and would lead to the immiediete cancellation of 616 or Ultimate titles. And then mentions that Cap is back in WWII
Sounds like a horrible move. Us modern folks can't even tell you when the War of 1812 was fought, let alone care about war stories.
Anonymous poster comes to the Internet and makes up complete crap. Seriously, if I make a new screen name and create some weird and elaborate storyline that "a friend" told me , will you all swallow it?
I wouldn't swallow it.
Yes, I agree with the rest of your post
(see my posts for a couple identical points)
Check it out: Shu and I (and FLCL) teamed up!