Marvel Universe >> View Post
Post By

Member Since: Sat May 17, 2008
Posts: 7,892
In Reply To

Subj: Actually...
Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2009 at 06:50:24 pm EST (Viewed 152 times)
Reply Subj: Review of Hulk vs Thor (long) Spoilers
Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2009 at 12:35:17 pm EST (Viewed 208 times)

> First off let me state I am a Thor fan. I loved the way Asgard was shown. The art and most of the voices were great. Most of the frequent named Asgardians were shown with the noticeable exception of Heimdall, and Balder had some made for TV outfit on. I didnt know who he was until someone said his name. Everyone was pretty much spot on with characterization. The Asgardians at first took it like a game and when they realized the seriousness of the situation they were not afraid and were willing to lay down their lives, the way heroes should. Loki was malicious and evil the way I like, the Enchantress was the in over her head accomplice that she usually is, and Hela was the imperial, haughty goddess of death that she should be.
> That storyline and dialog were also pretty good. Generic but reasonable explanation on why the Hulk was in Asgard and passable explanation on why the Hulk couldnt be teleported back to Earth. Whole thing wrapped up in a manner which made sense.
> The bad. Once again everyone is pimped to make the Hulk look good. Its so not necessarry aned I for one am sick of it. He ran thru the entire Asgardian army, individual god heroes, Loki AND Thor at the same time, like they were nothing. I get that it was Bannerless Hulk, rage and strength personified, but NEVER in the history of Marvel has Thor gotten demolished like this in a fight with the Hulk. Marvel need to treat the properties with respect and not at the xpense of others. If you have no knowledge of the history of Thor and Asgard or are a Hulk lover its a great movie. If You do know your history it will be another disappointing and disrespectful showing for Thor and Co.

I agree with everything you said regarding the good and the bad. Hulk fans will love it and Thor fans will try and stomach it. The producers stated in an interview that Thor would probable loose at first, but at some point would rally. I did not see any rallying. I only saw Thor get beat close to death twice unlike a certain short runt who was still fighting the Hulk at the end of his featurette and in an earlier fight nearly beat the hulk.

Oh, and slight correction. Thor has gotten beat that bad by a hulk once before. It is in that abysmal story where he first fought Red Hulk.