Previous Post Quote: Black Album is my favorite and it is supposed to be their most commercial. Quote: It was released at just the right time for me (1991, I was a teenager back then). Quote: Nothing Else Matters remains one the best comforting songs ever. For the record (see what I did there?) Metallica's Black Album is my favorite too. Every song I associate with the band is on that album with the exception of "For Whom the Bell Tolls" which was on Ride the Lightning.

Whoa, I'm right with you on that. The black album is my favorite and of the older songs, For Whom The Bell Tolls is my favorite. I like the S&M version, I think just because Hetfield says "you betcha!" more so than the symphony. Although Master of Puppets is a good tune, too.