Previous Post http://www.comicbookresources.com/columns/index.cgi?column=pipeline&article=2956 Apologies for the long link but I'll be a wheatcake eatin' fool if this doesn't actually sound plausible. . .

He's off base for three reasons:

1) He's basing a lot on the Knightfall analogy. That story involved radical progression, whereas this one involves radical regression.

2) The Batman editors hadn't been talking for years about how they wanted to get rid of Bruce Wayne.

3) Knightfall is an interesting narrative on its own merits, while "One More Day" is a transparent contrivance.