Dave Galanter
December 1st 1969 - December 12th 2020
He was loved.

Amazing Spider-Man Message Board >> View Post
·
Post By
Blargh

In Reply To
Dave Phelps

Subj: Re: Unlikely
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 at 11:36:41 am EST
Reply Subj: Re: Unlikely
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 at 10:43:10 am EST

Previous Post

> > I think the "silent majority" was thrilled to be able to get Wolverine and Spider-Man in the same book. More efficient that way. ;\)

By the way, I just wanted to mention that I think this is a key selling point for the non-Interneters.

> > Also, the book has had incentive variants or been involved in one event or another since it started so there's no way to what the "true fanbase" of the book is.
>
> The book has been involved in a total of one event (Civil War) though the team and characters have appeared in others and the book will be in Secret Invasion.

#16-20 dealt with the aftermath of House of M, #21-25 was Civil War, #26-31 (or thereabouts) was "the Initiative" (took awhile for folks to realize that wasn't necessarily an event, but the banner on the cover appeared to help bump up sales on books) and since then they've been gearing up for Secret Invasion.

> I haven't noticed an overt amount of variants. There was the first arc that had variants of each member by itself + a beautiful team variant, and then second printing ones on Civil War. No more, no less than any other new, hit title.

I know for a fact they had incentive variants on #7-10, cause I bought 'em. \:\) I'm not sure about since then.

(And I think any book, whether I like it or not, that uses variants is attempting to inflate their numbers so we don't get a feel for what the true readership really is.)

> > That said, Avengers has been a top 20/30 book for decades, no matter how popular or unpopular the creative team has been. Some folks just like their team books and don't care what the "critics" think.
>
> If anything, the critics agree with the buyers.

Since when? I almost never see a positive review of Avengers. Unless you mean the buyers who pick the book up even though they hate it, in which case, sure, okay. ;\)

> It's The Internet opinion that doesn't. And being a top 30 book is nothing to brag about.

Top 30 has expanded a bit in recent years, thanks to stuff like Countdown, various event books, etc. In terms of regular ongoings, I don't think Avengers has dipped below top 20 in a long time, if ever.

> For a team as important as Avengers, and titles such as Cap and IRon Man, to the MU, they should also be top sellers, and the current creative teams are doing that quite well than in the recent (5-7 years ago) past.

Sure. I just think there's more to it than everyone loving the book except for a handful of cranky Internet people. I'm sure it would still sell perfectly well without the gimmicks, but we have no real indication either way.


> #16-20 dealt with the aftermath of House of M,

It did, but it didn't have a House of M banner on it. Just because an arc follows up on an event doesn't make it an event, just as PAD dealt with The Other aftermath in FNSM but that didn't make 70% of PAD's run an event.

> Since when? I almost never see a positive review of Avengers. Unless you mean the buyers who pick the book up even though they hate it, in which case, sure, okay. ;\)

We can debate "Oh I hate it but I buy it cause blah blah" some other time, but:

http://www.spidermancrawlspace.com/miniseries/Avengers/index.html
Never dips below 3 webs. I know not exactly a professional review, but it's something.

New Avengers #15 got "must read" and "check it" from IGN: http://comics.ign.com/articles/684/684435p1.html

But for a top selling book, it's safe to assume that most people buying it actually like it. I really don't think there are 70,000 people out there who will buy a book they hate.


> Sure. I just think there's more to it than everyone loving the book except for a handful of cranky Internet people. I'm sure it would still sell perfectly well without the gimmicks, but we have no real indication either way.

By sales, it sure seems that way. Marvel doesn't distinguish between "collector who hates the book" and "loves the book" purchases. That and the Avengers board generally seems to like NA with, as with any media, exceptions.




Posted with Mozilla Firefox 2.0.0.11 on Windows XP
Alvaro's Comicboards powered by On Topic™ © 2003-2021 Powermad Software
All the content of these boards Copyright © 1996-2021 by Comicboards/TVShowboards. Software Copyright © 2003-2021 Powermad Software