Quote:Not really, imo, because frankly, I do not consider this to truly be Scott. It's Scott on Phoenix. He is being mind controlled.
Yeah, but Scott has been violent with Jean before- the most obvious example is X-Factor 18. The Phoenix just amplified Scott's existing tendencies. I agree that Scott's off the hook for choking Emma but I also think that he needs to take a closer look at his past behavior.
In X-Factor 18, he was being violent with what he thought was Phoenix. Just because people have tendencies doesn't mean the amplification of those tendencies is them. The very fact that his tendencies are being amplified beyond his control is mind control.